Mysterious Psychic Forces: An Account of the Author's Investigations in Psychical Research, Together with Those of Other European Savants
John Stuart Mill · en
"I? I haven't left this place."
Seeing the uselessness of further questions, we go to bed again,
advising her to sleep quietly.
Next day I ask her the same question. She is very much astonished and
even troubled (she blushes slightly).
"How should I dare," said she, "to enter your chamber during the
night?"
This accusation is very painful to her, and she tries to persuade us
by all kinds of insufficient reasons that we are wrong. She denies the
whole thing, and I am obliged to admit that she does not remember
getting up or _even having conversed with us_ (it was just another
somnambulistic state).
I take a little table, and direct Eusapia to put her hands on it.
"Very well," says she, "John will tell you that I don't lie."
I then ask the following questions:
"Is it you, John, who came into our sleeping chamber last night?"
"No."
"Was it the chambermaid?" (I suggest this idea for the express purpose
of testing John's veracity.)
"No," says he.
"Was it the medium herself?"
"Yes," says the table.--"No, it is not true," exclaims Eusapia, seeing
her hope banished--"Yes," replies the table, forcibly.
"Was she in the trance state?"
"No."
"In her normal state?"
"No."
"In a spontaneous somnambulistic state?"
"Yes."
"For what purpose?"
"_She was hunting matches; for she was frightened in her sleep, and
didn't want to sleep without light._"
Sure enough, there were always matches in the drawer opened by
Eusapia, except on this particular night. She therefore returned
without getting any.
While listening to the explanation of the table, Eusapia shrugged her
shoulders, but protested no longer.
Here, then, is a woman who, from time to time, has the power of
passing from one psychical state to another. Is it just to accuse such
a creature of premeditated fraud, without the slightest medical and
psychological examination, without the least attempt at
verification?...
M. Ochorowicz adds here that, so far as he is concerned, the phenomena are
not produced by a personality different from that of the medium, nor by a
new independent occult force; but it is a special psychic condition which
permits the vital _dynamism of the medium_ (the astral body of the
occultists) _to act at a distance_, under certain exceptional conditions.
It is the only hypothesis which seems _necessary in the actual state of
our knowledge_.
Why does the medium so often try to release her hand? So far as the
Cambridge experimenters are concerned, the cause is very simple and always
the same: she releases her hand in order to indulge in tricks. As a matter
of fact, the reasons why she frees her hand are many and complicated.
Dr. Ochorowicz's explanations are as follows: