Observations on antimony: Read before the Medical Society of London, and published at their request — John Stuart Mill — John Shaqi
Observations on antimony: Read before the Medical Society of London, and published at their request
John Stuart Mill · en
I have been desired to visit children and some grown persons in fevers,
attended with convulsions, which were, with good reason, attributed to
the misapplication of antimonials, and in one case an imprudent use of
them was judged to be the cause of death.
Though it is asserted that antimonial preparations may be so directed as
to vomit, purge, or sweat according to the intention of the prescriber,
yet those who have had much experience will not obstinately defend the
assertion, since nothing perhaps is more difficult than to foretel
their effects when administered alone. If they are combined with other
medicines their operation may be more certainly directed, since by opium
they may be determined to the skin, by senna or manna they may be carried
off by the intestines, and by an addition of ipecacuan or oxymel of
squills they may be rendered emetic.
But much prudence and skill are requisite in conducting the operation
of these compound medicines. For tho’ no danger were to be apprehended
from joining antimonials with emetics or purgatives, yet, by unskilful
combinations, the peculiar efficacy of antimony may be destroyed; and
by opiates those virulent particles may be retained, and prove noxious,
which would have been carried off, without any other inconvenience than
what might arise from the violence of their operation.
Upon the whole, the evidence in favour of antimony and its preparations
is too slight to justify the exaggerated encomiums with which it has been
extolled: it contains in its crude state, and in all its preparations,
such virulent particles as may, by slight accidents, become poisonous in
the stomach: well-attested instances of remarkable cures performed by
it are few; cases in which it has failed or been prejudicial, numerous;
the reports of chymists and physicians concerning it are various and
contradictory; its effects are precarious, and more skill, experience
and attention requisite to conduct its operation than are to be expected
among the generality, even of regular practitioners[71]. It is therefore
very improper for common use; and as there is no certain rule to direct
the management of it, every physician must form his judgment by comparing
his own observations with the opposite and contradictory assertions of
others.
It would be imprudent to reprobate a medicine which, in some instances,
has certainly performed such cures as are seldom obtained by milder
methods. No bounds are to be fixed to discreet and experienced
practitioners, who, on mature deliberation, may determine the propriety
of hazarding, in particular circumstances, a violent and precarious
remedy, and can conduct its operation with skill and sagacity. Yet the
present indiscriminate use of antimony, which is now grown up into a
fashion too formidable to be attacked with much hope of success, must,
after a candid and impartial examination, be condemned as pernicious.
SECTION V.