Principles of Political Economy: Abridged with Critical, Bibliographical, and Explanatory Notes, and a Sketch of the History of Political Economy
John Stuart Mill · en
The mere fact that the silver dollar-piece had not circulated
since even long before 1853 led the authorities to drop out the
provisions for the coinage of silver dollars and in 1873 remove it
from the list of legal coins (at the ratio of 1 to 15.98, the
obsolete ratio fixed as far back as 1834). This is what is known
as the “demonetization” of silver. It had no effect on the
circulation of silver dollars, since none were in use, and had not
been for more than twenty-five years. There had been no desire up
to this time to use silver, since it was more expensive than gold;
indeed, it is somewhat humiliating to our sense of national honor
to reflect that it was not until silver fell so surprisingly in
value (in 1876) that the agitation for its use in the coinage
arose. When a silver dollar was worth 104 cents, no one wanted it
as a means of liquidating debts; when it came to be worth 86
cents, it was capable of serving debtors even better than the then
appreciating greenbacks. Thus, while from 1853 (and even before)
we had legally two standards, of both gold and silver, but really
only one, that of gold, from 1873 to 1878 we had both legally and
really only one standard, that of gold.
It might be here added, that I have spoken of the silver dollar as
containing 371-¼ grains of pure silver. Of course, alloy is mixed
with the pure silver, sufficient, in 1792, to make the original
dollar weigh 416 grains in all, its “standard” weight. In 1837 the
amount of alloy was changed from 1/12 to 1/10 of the standard
weight, which (as the 371-¼ grains of pure silver were unchanged)
gave the total weight of the dollar as 412-½ grains, whence the
familiar name assigned to this piece. In 1873, moreover, the mint
was permitted to put its stamp and devices—to what was not money
at all, but a “coined ingot”—on 378 grains of pure silver (420
grains, standard), known as the “trade-dollar.” It was intended by
this means to make United States silver more serviceable in the
Asiatic trade. Oriental nations care almost exclusively for silver
in payments. The Mexican silver dollar contained 377-¼ grains of
pure silver; the Japanese yen, 374-4/10; and the United States
dollar, 371-¼. By making the “trade-dollar” slightly heavier than
any coin used in the Eastern world, it would give our silver a new
market; and the United States Government was simply asked to
certify to the fineness and weight by coining it, provided the
owners of silver paid the expenses of coinage. Inadvertently the
trade-dollar was included in the list of coins in the act of 1873
which were legal tender for payments of five dollars, but, when
this was discovered, it was repealed in 1876. So that the
trade-dollar was not a legal coin, in any sense (although it
contained more silver than the 412-½-grains dollar). They ceased