Principles of Political Economy: Abridged with Critical, Bibliographical, and Explanatory Notes, and a Sketch of the History of Political Economy
John Stuart Mill · en
to be coined in 1878, to which time there had been made
$35,959,360.
IV. In February, 1878, an indiscreet and unreasonable movement
induced Congress to authorize the recoinage of the silver
dollar-piece at the obsolete ratio of 1834 (1 to 15.98), while the
market ratio was 1 to 17.87. So extraordinary a reversal of all
sound principles and such blindness to our previous experience
could be explained only by a desire to force this country to use a
silver coinage only, and had its origin with the owners of
silver-mines, aided by the desires of debtors for a cheap unit in
which to absolve themselves from their indebtedness. There was no
pretense of setting up a double standard about it; for it was
evident to the most ignorant that so great a disproportion between
the mint and market ratios must inevitably lead to the
disappearance of gold entirely. This would happen, if owners could
bring their silver freely, in any amounts, to the mint for coinage
(“Free Coinage”), and so exchange silver against gold coin for the
purpose of withdrawing gold, since gold would exchange for less as
coin than as bullion. This immediate result was prevented by a
provision in the law, which prevented the “free coinage” of
silver, and required the Government itself to buy silver and coin
at least $2,000,000 in silver each month. This retarded, but will
not ultimately prevent, the change from the present gold to a
single silver standard. At the rate of $24,000,000 a year, it is
only a question of time when the Treasury will be obliged to pay
out, for its regular disbursements on the public debt, silver in
such amounts as will drive gold out of circulation. In February,
1884, it was feared that this was already at hand, and was
practically reached in the August following. Unless a repeal of
the law is reached very soon, the uncomfortable spectacle will be
seen of a gradual disarrangement of prices, and consequently of
trade, arising from a change of the standard.
In order that the alternate movements of silver and gold to the
mint for coinage may be seen, there is appended a statement of the
coinage(239) during the above periods, which well shows the
effects of Gresham’s law.
Ratio in the mint and in Period. Gold coinage. Silver dollars
the market. coined.
1:15 (silver lower in 1792-1834 $11,825,890 $36,275,077
market)
1:15.98 (gold lower in 1834-1853 224,965,730 42,936,294
market)
1:15.98 (gold lower in 1853-1873 544,864,921 5,538,948
market)
Single gold standard. 1873-1878 166,253,816 ........
1:15.98 (silver lower, 1878-1883 354,019,865 147,255,899
but no free coinage)