"What is competition from the point of view of the workman? It
is work put up to auction. A contractor wants a workman: three
present themselves.--How much for your work?--Half-a-crown; I
have a wife and children.--Well; and how much for yours?--Two
shillings: I have no children, but I have a wife.--Very well;
and now how much for you?--One and eightpence are enough for me;
I am single. Then you shall have the work. It is done; the
bargain is struck. And what are the other two workmen to do? It
is to be hoped they will die quietly of hunger. But what if they
take to thieving? Never fear; we have the police. To murder? We
have got the hangman. As for the lucky one, his triumph is only
temporary. Let a fourth workman make his appearance, strong
enough to fast every other day, and his price will run down
still lower; then there will be a new outcast, a new recruit for
the prison perhaps!
"Will it be said that these melancholy results are exaggerated;
that at all events they are only possible when there is not work
enough for the hands that seek employment? But I ask, in answer,
Does the principle of competition contain, by chance, within
itself any method by which this murderous disproportion is to be
avoided? If one branch of industry is in want of hands, who can
answer for it that, in the confusion created by universal
competition, another is not overstocked? And if, out of
thirty-four millions of men, twenty are really reduced to theft
for a living, this would suffice to condemn the principle.
"But who is so blind as not to see that under the system of
unlimited competition, the continual fall of wages is no
exceptional circumstance, but a necessary and general fact? Has
the population a limit which it cannot exceed? Is it possible
for us to say to industry--industry given up to the accidents of
individual egotism and fertile in ruin--can we say, 'Thus far
shalt thou go, and no farther?' The population increases
constantly: tell the poor mother to become sterile, and
blaspheme the God who made her fruitful, for if you do not, the
lists will soon become too narrow for the combatants. A machine
is invented: command it to be broken, and anathematize science,
for if you do not, the thousand workmen whom the new machine
deprives of work will knock at the door of the neighboring
workshop, and lower the wages of their companions. Thus
systematic lowering of wages, ending in the driving out of a
certain number of workmen, is the inevitable effect of unlimited
competition. It is an industrial system by means of which the
working-classes are forced to exterminate one another."
* * * * *