Spiritualism and the New Psychology: An Explanation of Spiritualist Phenomena and Beliefs in Terms of Modern Knowledge — John Stuart Mill — John Shaqi
Spiritualism and the New Psychology: An Explanation of Spiritualist Phenomena and Beliefs in Terms of Modern Knowledge
John Stuart Mill · en
The word 'hysteria', like 'lunacy', is evidence of a belief now
discarded. When the theory of demoniacal possession ceased to satisfy
the desire for reasons, and material explanations were sought for
certain conditions, it was supposed that the uterus (Greek, _hystera_)
came adrift from its position and wandered about the body, producing the
condition thenceforward known as hysteria. Advancing knowledge killed
this theory, but the influence of the word remained and the disease was
attributed to some derangement or irritation of the uterus and its
associated organs. Charcot, of Paris, showed the mental origin of
hysteria, but, becoming lost in a maze of hypnotism and suggestion, he
described as symptoms of the disease various manifestations which were
really called up by himself or his assistants. There are medical men who
still insist on a bodily cause, but such causes serve merely as pegs on
which to hang the symptoms.
As usual, I shrink from a definition, but in this case I have good
reason. Every writer who describes hysteria expresses his own ideas
about it, and as the ideas of no two writers are alike some definitions
scarcely seem to refer to the same subject.
Here is a definition by Babinski, a French writer of international
reputation:--
'Hysteria is a peculiar psychical state capable of giving rise to
certain conditions which have features of their own. It manifests
itself in primary and secondary symptoms. The former can be exactly
reproduced by suggestion in certain subjects and can be made to
disappear under the sole influence of suggestion.'
And here is one by Pierre Janet, a man of equal eminence:--
'Hysteria is a form of mental depression characterised by
retraction of the field of personal consciousness, and a tendency
to complete division of the personality, and subconscious mental
conditions grow and form a kind of second personality.'
And here are a few words from Ernest Jones, the chief exponent of
Freud's views in this country:--
'It is in the excessive tendency to displace affects by means of
superficial associations that the final key to the explanation of
abnormal suggestion is to be sought. Even if it were true, which it
certainly is not, that most hysterical symptoms are the product of
verbal suggestion, the observation would be of hardly any practical
or theoretical interest.'
When the reader has finished this chapter he will perhaps return to
these definitions, and see how each represents one aspect, and how the
best understanding is reached by a consideration of all of them.