The Beauty and the Bolshevist — John Stuart Mill — John Shaqi
The Beauty and the Bolshevist
John Stuart Mill · en
In short, it was hardly to be expected that the discussion would be
amicable, and it was not. Each man began to be angry in his own way.
Eddie shouted a little, and Ben expressed himself with turns of phrase
quite needlessly insulting. Ben found Verriman’s assumption that the
profits of capital were bound up with patriotism, family life, and the
Christian religion almost as irritating as Verriman found Ben’s
assumption that the government of labor as a class would be entirely
without the faults that have always marked every form of class
government.
“And suppose you got socialism,” said Eddie, at last, “suppose you did
divide everything up equally, don’t you suppose that in a few years the
clever, strong, industrious men would have it all in their own hands?”
“Very likely,” said Ben, “but that would be quite a change from the
present arrangement, wouldn’t it?”
Mr. Cord had a narrow escape from laughing out loud, which would have
cost him the friendship of the man with whom on the whole he really
agreed. He thought it was time to interfere.
“This is very interesting, Mr. Moreton,” he said, “but I fancy it
wasn’t about the general radical propaganda that you came to see me.”
“No,” said Ben, turning slowly. He felt as a dog feels who is dragged
out of the fight just as it begins to get exciting. “No, I came to see
you about this unfortunate engagement of my brother’s.”
“Unfortunate?” asked Mr. Cord, without criticism.
“I should consider it so, and I understand you do, too.”
Cord did not move an eyelash; this was an absolutely new form of
attack. It had certainly never crossed his mind that any objection
could come from the Moreton family.
“You consider it unfortunate?” said Eddie, as if it would be mere
insolence on Ben’s part to object to his brother’s marrying anyone.
“Will you give me your reasons for objecting?” said Cord.
Ben smiled. “You ought to understand them,” he said, “for I imagine
they’re pretty much the same as your own. I mean they are both founded
on class consciousness. I feel that it will be destructive to the
things I value most in David to be dependent on, or associated with,
the capitalistic group. Just as you feel it will be destructive to your
daughter to be married to a tutor—a fellow with radical views and a
seditious brother—”
“One moment, one moment,” said Cord; “you’ve got this all wrong so far
as I’m concerned. I do most emphatically disagree with the radical
propaganda. I think the radical is usually just a man who hasn’t got
something he wants.”
“And the conservative is a man who wants to keep something he’s got,”
said Ben, less hostilely than he had spoken to Eddie.
“Exactly, exactly,” said Cord. “In ideality there isn’t much to choose
between them, but, generally speaking, I have more respect for the man
who has succeeded in getting something to preserve than for the man who
hasn’t got anything to lose.”
“If their opportunities were equal.”