The electron, its isolation and measurement and the determination of some of its properties
John Stuart Mill · en
That and computed from the law of fall become farther
and farther removed from the values of and computed from
the Brownian movements, the smaller these particles appear to be, is
just what would be expected if the particles under consideration have
surface impurities or non-spherical shapes or else are not mercury at
all.[124] If, further, exact multiple relations hold for them, as at
least a dozen of us, including Dr. Ehrenhaft himself, now find that
they invariably do, there is scarcely any other interpretation possible
except that of incorrect assumptions as to density.[see footnote 124] Again, the fact
that these data are all taken when the observers are working with the
exceedingly dense substances, mercury and gold, volatilized in an
electric arc, and when, therefore, anything not mercury or gold,
but assumed to be, would yield very low values of and , is
in itself a very significant circumstance. The further fact that Dr.
Ehrenhaft implies that normal values of e very frequently appear in
his work,[125] while these low erratic drops represent only a part
of the data taken, is suggestive. When one considers, too, that in
[Pg 174]
place of the beautiful consistency and duplicability shown in the
oil-drop work, Dr. Ehrenhaft and his pupils never publish data on any
two particles which yield the same value of , but instead find
only irregularities and erratic behavior,[126] just as they would
expect to do with non-uniform particles, or with particles having dust
specks attached to them, one wonders why any explanation other than
the foreign-material one, which explains all the difficulties, has
ever been thought of. As a matter of fact, in our work with mercury
droplets, we have found that the initial rapid evaporation gradually
ceases, just as though the droplets had become coated with some foreign
film which prevents further loss. Dr. Ehrenhaft himself, in speaking
of the Brownian movements of his metal particles, comments on the fact
that they seem at first to show large movements which grow smaller with
time.[127] This is just what would happen if the radius were increased
by the growth of a foreign film.