The Foot-prints of the Creator : $b or, The Asterolepis of Stromness
John Stuart Mill · en
and the older ichthyologists; for it is a classification founded, not
on the character of the internal but on that of the cuticular or dermal
skeleton. And while to the geologist it possesses great and obvious
advantages over every other,—for of the earlier fishes very little more
than the cuticular skeleton survives,—it has this further recommendation
to the naturalist, that, (in so far at least as its author has been true
to his own principles,) instead of anomalously uniting the highest and
lowest specimens of their class,—the fishes that most nearly approximate
to the reptiles on the one hand, and the fishes that sink furthest
towards the worms on the other,—it gathers into one consistent order all
the individuals of the higher type, distinguished above their fellows
by their development of brain, the extensive range of their instincts,
and the perfection of their generative systems. Further, the history of
animal existences, as recorded in the sedimentary rocks of our planet,
reads a recommendation of this scheme of classification which it extends
to no other. We find that in the progress of creation the fishes _began
to be_ by groupes and septs, arranged according to the principle on which
it erects its orders. The Placoids came first, the Ganoids succeeded
them, and the Ctenoids and Cycloids brought up the rear. The march has
been marshalled according to an appointed programme, the order of which
it is peculiarly the merit of Agassiz to have ascertained.
Now, may I request the reader to mark, in the first place that what we
have specially to deal with at the present stage of the argument are the
Placoid fishes of the Silurian formations, Upper and Lower. May I ask him
to take note, in the second, that the long-fronted _chondropterygian_
series of Cuvier, though it includes, as has already been said, the
Placoid order of Agassiz,—just as the red-blooded division of animals
includes the bimana and quadrumana,—is no more to be regarded as
_identical_ with the Placoids, than the red-blooded animals are to be
regarded as identical with the apes or with the human family. It simply
includes them in the character of _one_ of the three great divisions into
which it has been separated,—the division ranged, if I may so express
myself, on the extreme right of the line; its middle portion, or main
body, being composed of the _Sturiones_, a family on the general level of
the osseous fishes; while, ranged on the extreme left, we find the low
division of the _Suctorii_, _i. e._ Cyclostomi, or Lampreys. But with
the middle and lower divisions we have at present nothing to do; for of
neither of them, whether _Sturiones_ or _Suctorii_, does the Silurian
System exhibit a trace. Further be it remarked, that the scheme of
classification which gives an abstract standing to the _Chondropterygii_,
is in itself merely a certain perception of resemblance which existed
in certain minds, having _cartilage_ for its general idea; just as