The Millbank Case: A Maine Mystery of To-day — John Stuart Mill — John Shaqi
The Millbank Case: A Maine Mystery of To-day
John Stuart Mill · en
“Of course,” she said; “the woman would prefer, greatly prefer, that
the secret should have died with the man who shared it with her.
Failing that, she could not feel safer than to have it in the hands
of such a man as you describe. There is, however, I should think, one
further assurance that she might desire.”
“I think if it were a possible thing to promise, the man as I know him
would be disposed to promise.”
“It is that if at any time in the future it should seem to him that
the woman was concerned in the crime, if there arise any circumstances
that call for explanation, he will come to her and first submit them to
her. I think under these circumstances, he might largely rely upon her
telling him the truth--at least, upon her not telling him a falsehood.”
“Of course,” he said, “I speak only of my impression, but that is that
she may rely absolutely upon his adopting this course.”
“I trust this enables us to end this interview,” she said, with no
relaxation of her dignity.
CHAPTER VII
Hunting Broken Bones
Millbank cherished its tragedy as something that gave it pre-eminence
among its neighbours, and half the male population turned detectives on
the spot. To many members of the community, however, the affair bore
a most serious aspect, heightened by the conviction that no actual
progress had been made towards the solution of the mystery. Such men
as McManus, the county attorney, and the town counsel, looked upon
the testimony which tended to implicate Oldbeg as a concession to the
public demand that something should be done, and as covering rather
than revealing the serious business of the investigation. They were
inclined to be indignant at what they regarded as the direction of
unjust suspicion against an innocent person, and the more so when they
saw how public sentiment was roused against the unfortunate man.
In fact, there were whispers among the least responsible that if the
law was to interpose delays, it might become the duty of the citizens
to take the execution of justice into their own hands. It was the
county judge who first called attention to the danger to the town and
county that lurked in such loose talk, indulged in at the start by idle
men and boys, but working as a leaven that might finally affect the
entire community.
“There’s just the material down there to give your town a blacker
tragedy than it’s had yet,” he said to McManus one day after court.
“The guilty had better go unpunished than be punished through violation
of the law.”
McManus turned sharply, with that nervous quickness that made him
forget the judge in the speaker:
“The guilty! The guilty! No man is guilty till the law has found him
so! How long since suspicion was proof?”
The judge, who appreciated the strain which the death of his partner
and friend had thrown upon McManus, let the brusqueness of the answer
pass, but still was insistent: