The old South : $b A monograph — John Stuart Mill — John Shaqi
The old South : $b A monograph
John Stuart Mill · en
The Old South, in itself and apart from all other considerations,
will always be a profitable study. It is the one unique page of our
national history. Indeed, it comprehends two hundred and fifty years
of history with scarce a parallel. I think one will search in vain
history, ancient or modern, to find a likeness to the Old South,
socially, intellectually, politically, or religiously. I do not
wonder that romancer, poet, historian, and philosopher have gathered
from it material and inspiration. As a matter of fact, the past
decade has brought forth more literature concerning the Old South
than the entire generation which preceded it. Its body lies moldering
in the ground, but its soul goes marching on. Wherein especially was
it unique?
To begin with, it was in the South rather than the North that the
seed of American liberty was first planted. Jamestown, not Plymouth
Rock, was the matrix of true Americanism. Poet and orator have made
much of the rock-bound coast and savage wild to which the Puritan
fathers came, and have had little to say of the Cavaliers who fought
their way to conquest over savage beast and man. Winthrop, Standish,
and Cotton Mather are set forth by provincial and partisan writer
and speaker as exclusive national types of pioneer courage, wisdom,
and heroism. I have read more than one sneer in alleged national
histories against “the gentlemen of Jamestown,” of whom it was said
that there were “eleven laboring men and thirty-five gentlemen.” But
the historians who sneer fail to note how these same gentlemen felled
more trees and did more hard work than the men of the ax and pick.
Long after Jamestown had become a memory, I had seen the descendants
of those same derided gentlemen in the Army of Northern Virginia,
possessors of inherited wealth and reared to luxury from their
cradles, yet toiling in the trenches or tramping on the dusty highway
or charging into the mouth of cannon with unfailing cheerfulness.
I do not disparage the stern integrity and high achievement of the
Puritan sires. I gladly accord them a high place among the fathers
and founders of the republic. But putting Puritan and Cavalier
side by side, rating each fairly at his real worth and by what he
did to fix permanently the qualities that have made us great, I am
confident I could make good my proposition that deeper down at the
foundation of our greatness as a people than all other influences are
the qualities and spirit that have marked the Cavalier in the Old
World or the New.
[Illustration: AUNT HANNAH.]