The Quakers, Past and Present — John Stuart Mill — John Shaqi
The Quakers, Past and Present
John Stuart Mill · en
But the swing-back for the imitative mass to the easily grasped dogma of
an infallible Scripture did not take place at once. It appears as a
clearly accomplished fact at the time of the mid-eighteenth-century
departure of Quakerism on its second missionary effort. Meanwhile, we
must consider the intervening hundred years--the second period of
Quakerism--generally known as the century of Quietism.
The first generation of Quakers had passed away. The great mission--the
going forth to win mankind to live by the Inner Light--had failed.
Better fitted, apparently, than any since the early Christians to
evangelize the world, catholic to the limit of the term, knowing nothing
of "heathen" nor of any "living in darkness"; a body of devotees culled
from all existing groups, hampered by no official church, unhindered by
luxury, undaunted by distance and difficulty, working in the open under
storms of persecution that had driven their companion groups to hiding
or dissolution, the Friends of Truth had failed to bring even the
churches to the acknowledgment of that on which they all ultimately
rested. Passing through European Christendom and beyond, they gathered
in their fellows, retreated to camp, gave up their original enterprise,
and became a separatist sect. The greater number of them were
flourishing tradespeople, owing their success in business largely to the
fact that, whereas trade as a whole was still subject to those passions
which had called forth in old times the law forbidding any transaction
beyond the sum of twenty pennies to be made without the presence of the
port-reeve or other responsible third person, here were men who required
neither bond nor agreement, who were as good as their word, asking one
price for their goods, and refusing to bargain. Their social life at the
beginning of the second period has been described for us by one of the
last of the earlier generation, coming late in life to English Quaker
circles after twenty years of absence. William Bromfield was a medical
man who had followed James II. to Ireland because of his goodness to the
Quakers, had served him for years in Paris as his secretary, and had
suffered imprisonment in the Bastille for conscience' sake. At one
moment we see him visiting a Trappist monastery, explaining to the
Fathers the Quaker faith and manner of living--the Trappists
acknowledging the Quakers as ripe for sainthood--and then we read of his
bitter disillusionment. He finds[14] "riches, pride, arrogancy, and
falling into parties." He notes with grief that onlookers are saying
"that the Quakers, who might have converted the world had they kept
their first faith, are now become apostates and hypocrites, as vain in
their Conversation, Habits, and Dresses, as any other people." Even the
poor tradesmen and mechanics amongst them wore periwigs: "a wicked
covering of Horse-hair and Goats'-hair." Men were "trick'd out in cock'd
Hats, their fine Cloathes with their Cuts _à la mode_ and long cravats."