Thunder and Lightning — John Stuart Mill — John Shaqi
Thunder and Lightning
John Stuart Mill · en
But behold, the lightning intervened; the tree was struck, and the
open chest was thrown on the highway, where it was found by a peasant.
Animals are worse treated than men, but better than plants and
inorganic bodies. What are the causes of this difference? Can we
attribute it to physical predisposition? But this has not yet been
proved. Experience shows that sparks directed on the vertebral column
are particularly dangerous. Now, the backs of quadrupeds are greatly
exposed to mortal strokes from the celestial fire.
Their fur or their plumage, which form an intrinsic part of their
bodies, put them more or less in the situation of a man who, to
protect himself from inclemency, should envelop himself in his hair,
supposing this to be long enough and rich enough to cover him
decently.
Animals rarely survive when struck. When they do not die on the spot,
they succumb soon after to their wounds. The ancients have remarked on
this.
"Man," says Pliny, "is the only animal that lightning does not always
kill; all the others die on the spot. It is a prerogative granted to
him by Nature, though so many animals surpass him in strength." And,
further on, he adds that amongst birds the eagle is never struck. This
has given it the name of _porte foudre_.
But these assertions are slightly exaggerated, and we can quote a
certain number of examples of animals which have resisted the baneful
influence of the electric current.
In 1901, a horse was touched by lightning, which was certainly
attracted by the iron of his shoe. It traced two deep trails right
along the animal's leg, where the skin was abrased, and appeared as
though it were cauterized. These two lines joined together at the fold
of the ham, and then formed a single furrow, all sign of which was
lost in the abdominal region. The rest of the body was unhurt, and the
animal sustained no further harm after being struck than it would have
done if an incompetent veterinary surgeon had fired him too severely.
On July 4, 1884, at Castres, ten persons and nine horses were struck
by lightning; all survived the accident.
On June 9, 1886, in the Grand Duchy of Luxembourg, three cows and a
little girl, who was in charge of them, were knocked over by a violent
shock. The child and the beasts soon got up. Only an ox was killed
some distance from there.
Very often horses are stunned by the discharge on animals which are
killed, but after a time they recover. This phenomenon has also been
observed in other animals. For instance, five or six pigs which were
in a cage in the prow of a ship were killed by an electric discharge,
whilst others which were only separated from them by a cloth were
saved.
But the cases are rare in which animals do not succumb to lightning.
They nearly always perish. At present we will only discuss animals as
a body, equal, or superior to man. The others, the smaller ones,
offer a still more convincing generality.