Windmills: A book of fables — John Stuart Mill — John Shaqi
Windmills: A book of fables
John Stuart Mill · en
“And that,” put in Siebenhaar, “is where he is consistent. He is like
all the men of his time and condition; he does not mind living, in
fact he quite likes it, so long as he knows nothing about it and is
not called upon to realise what he is doing. When he is faced with the
consequences of such insensibility he is so appalled that he welcomes
the idea of death, if he can find some excuse for it. Therefore he
has invented a myth called his country and proposes to die for that.
According to his prejudices it is cowardly to draw a fire-arm upon
himself, but it is right and brave to place himself in the line of
some one else’s fire. Such a condition of imbecility is extremely
infectious. It sweeps through crowds of men like a disease through
cattle. But, as men are indomitably hopeful, they do not destroy each
other, as you, Ultimus, might suppose. No, they wait until they can
discover another crowd of men in the same lamentable condition, and
fall upon them in the hope of a victory which shall restore their
self-conceit and once more blind them to the appalling consequences of
their own ill-doing. And here, at last, we do touch upon one of the
prime causes of war. Superficially it looks as though the immediate
cause was this, that the governors of States make such a mess of the
affairs with which they are entrusted and reduce their people to so
lamentable a condition that they must seek war as an outlet, and to
give the male populace as soldiers the food which they have made it
impossible for them to earn as workers. There is also the consideration
that a large proportion of the male populace will be removed from all
possibility of making trouble. That is an interesting but a superficial
view which attaches more blame to the rich than they deserve. No. A
more profound analysis gives us the result I have previously indicated,
that wars are invariably due to moral epidemics. And, since the human
race will always be subject to them, there will always be war.”
Ultimus had withdrawn at the beginning of the discussion. Having no
knowledge of men in herds, he could not follow the line of Siebenhaar’s
argument. He returned now to say that he had obliterated another
battle. On this the Rear-Admiral was excited and wished to know what
ships he had seen and what flag they were flying.
“I do not know,” replied Ultimus, “but there were nine ships attacking
three and that struck me as so unfair that I decided to make an end of
it.”
“But they may have been Fattish ships! Have you no regard for human
life?”
Said Ultimus:
“There was no sign of anything human. They looked like flies on the
water. When I see three scorpions attacking a smaller insect I always
kill the scorpions for their cowardice and the insect for having called
down their anger upon itself.”
Rear-Admiral Bich drew himself up to his full height and said: