Overtones, a book of temperaments : $b Richard Strauss, Parsifal, Verdi, Balzac, Flaubert, Nietzsche, and Turgénieff
Nietzsche · en
The Hero theme is Beethovian in its diatonic majesty—the
entire section has a Beethoven color, despite its dissonantal
interruptions—while the second section, an amiable picture of the
composer’s adversaries, suggests in a triturated manner the irony,
caricature, and burlesque spirit of Till Eulenspiegel. His critical
adversaries are represented as a snarling, sorry crew, with acrid
and acrimonious souls, duly set forth by the woodwind instruments,
chiefly the oboe; there is also a horrid sounding phrase, empty
fifths for tenor and bass tuba. Then the hero’s wife is pictured
by the solo violin. It is very feminine. It mounts in passion
and interest with the duologue. After that—chaos! It is but the
developing of the foregoing motives. And such an exposition, it
is safe to say, has never been heard since saurians roared in the
steaming marshes of the young planet, or when prehistoric man met in
multitudinous and shrieking combat. Yet the web is polyphonically
spun—spun magnificently. This battle scene is full of unmitigated
horror. One knows that it is the free fantasia, but such a one has
never been conceived before by the mind of man. A battle is not a
peaceful or a pleasant place, especially a modern battlefield. You
can dimly, after several hearings, thread the thematic mazes, but so
discordant are the opposing tonalities, so screaming the harmonies,
and so highly pitched the dynamic scheme, that the normal ear, thus
rudely assaulted, becomes bewildered and finally insensitive. Strauss
has not a normal ear. His is the most marvelous agglomeration of
cortical cells that science has ever recorded. So acute are his
powers of acoustical differentiation that he must hear, not alone
tones beyond the base and the top of the normal scale unheard of
by ordinary humans, but he must also hear, or, rather, overhear,
the vibratory waves from all individual sounds. His music gives
us the impression of new overtones, of scales that violate the
well tempered, of tonalities that approximate to the quarter-tones
of Oriental music. And yet there is, besides the barbaric energy
displayed, grandeur in the conception of this extraordinary battle
piece. It evokes the picture of countless and waging hosts; of
forests of waving spears and clashing blades. The din, heat, and
turmoil of conflict are spread over all and the ground piled high
with the slain.