Plato and the Other Companions of Sokrates, 3rd ed. Volume 1 — Plato — John Shaqi
Plato and the Other Companions of Sokrates, 3rd ed. Volume 1
Plato · en
Extent of efficacious influence claimed by Sokrates for
himself--exemplified by Plato throughout the Dialogues of
Search--Xenophon and Plato enlarge it _ib._
Assumption by modern critics, that Sokrates is a positive teacher,
employing indirect methods for the inculcation of theories of his
own 419
Incorrectness of such assumption--the Sokratic Elenchus does not
furnish a solution, but works upon the mind of the respondent,
stimulating him to seek for a solution of his own 420
Value and importance of this process--stimulating active individual
minds to theorise each for itself 421
View taken by Sokrates about death. Other men profess to know what it
is, and think it a great misfortune: he does not know 422
Reliance of Sokrates on his own individual reason, whether agreeing or
disagreeing with others 423
Formidable efficacy of established public beliefs, generated without
any ostensible author 424
CHAPTER X.
Kriton.
General purpose of the Kriton 425
Subject of the dialogue--interlocutors _ib._
Answer of Sokrates to the appeal made by Kriton 426
He declares that the judgment of the general public is not worthy of
trust: he appeals to the judgment of the one Expert, who is wise on
the matter in debate _ib._
Principles laid down by Sokrates for determining the question with
Kriton. Is the proceeding recommended just or unjust? Never in any
case to act unjustly 427
Sokrates admits that few will agree with him, and that most persons
hold the opposite opinion: but he affirms that the point is cardinal
_ib._
Pleading supposed to be addressed by the Laws of Athens to Sokrates,
demanding from him implicit obedience 428
Purpose of Plato in this pleading--to present the dispositions of
Sokrates in a light different from that which the Apology had
presented--unqualified submission instead of defiance _ib._
Harangue of Sokrates delivered in the name of the Laws, would have
been applauded by all the democratical patriots of Athens 430
The harangue insists upon topics common to Sokrates with other
citizens, overlooking the specialties of his character 431
Still Sokrates is represented as adopting the resolution to obey, from
his own conviction; by a reason which weighs with him, but which would
not weigh with others _ib._
The harangue is not a corollary from this Sokratic reason, but
represents feelings common among Athenian citizens 432
Emphatic declaration of the authority of individual reason and
conscience, for the individual himself _ib._
The Kriton is rhetorical, not dialectical. Difference between Rhetoric
and Dialectic 433
The Kriton makes powerful appeal to the emotions, but overlooks the
ratiocinative difficulties, or supposes them to be solved _ib._
Incompetence of the general public or [Greek: i)diô=tai]--appeal to
the professional Expert 435
Procedure of Sokrates after this comparison has been declared--he does
not name who the trustworthy Expert is _ib._