Plato and the Other Companions of Sokrates, 3rd ed. Volume 2 — Plato — John Shaqi
Plato and the Other Companions of Sokrates, 3rd ed. Volume 2
Plato · en
Plato's demonstration of the immortality of the soul rests
upon the assumption of the Platonic ideas. Reasoning to prove this 412
The soul always brings life, and is essentially living. It
cannot receive death: in other words, it is immortal 413
The proof of immortality includes pre-existence as well as
post-existence--animals as well as man--also the metempsychosis or
translation of the soul from one body to another 414
After finishing his proof that the soul is immortal,
Sokrates enters into a description, what will become of it after the
death of the body. He describes a [Greek: Nekui/a] 415
Sokrates expects that his soul is going to the islands of
the blest. Reply to Kriton about burying his body 416
Preparations for administering the hemlock. Sympathy of
the gaoler. Equanimity of Sokrates _ib._
Sokrates swallows the poison. Conversation with the gaoler 417
Ungovernable sorrow of the friends present. Self-command
of Sokrates. Last words to Kriton, and death _ib._
Extreme pathos, and probable trustworthiness of these
personal details 419
Contrast between the Platonic Apology and the Phædon _ib._.
Abundant dogmatic and poetical invention of the Phædon
compared with the profession of ignorance which we read in the
Apology 421
Total renunciation and discredit of the body in the Phædon.
Different feeling about the body in other Platonic dialogues 422
Plato's argument does not prove the immortality of the
soul. Even if it did prove that, yet the mode of pre-existence and
the mode of post-existence, of the soul, would be quite undetermined 423
The philosopher will enjoy an existence of pure soul
unattached to any body 425
Plato's demonstration of the immortality of the soul did
not appear satisfactory to subsequent philosophers. The question
remained debated and problematical 426
PLATO.
CHAPTER XII
ALKIBIADES I. AND II.
ALKIBIADES I.--ON THE NATURE OF MAN.
[Side-note: Situation supposed in the dialogue.
Persons--Sokrates and Alkibiades.]