Plato and the Other Companions of Sokrates, 3rd ed. Volume 3 — Plato — John Shaqi
Plato and the Other Companions of Sokrates, 3rd ed. Volume 3
Plato · en
Aristotle assumes without proof, that there are some propositions
true, others false 249
Plato in the Sophistês has undertaken an impossible task--He could
not have proved, against his supposed adversary, that there _are_
false propositions _ib._
What must be assumed in all dialectic discussion 251
Discussion and theorising presuppose belief and disbelief,
expressed in set forms of words. They imply predication, which
Antisthenes discarded 252
Precepts and examples of logical partition, illustrated in the
Sophistês 253
Recommendation of logical bipartition 254
Precepts illustrated by the Philêbus _ib._
Importance of founding logical Partition on resemblances perceived
by sense 255
Province of sensible perception--is not so much narrowed by Plato
here as it is in the Theætêtus 256
Comparison of the Sophistês with the Phædrus 257
Comparison of the Politikus with the Parmenidês 258
Variety of method in dialectic research--Diversity of Plato 259
CHAPTER XXX.
POLITIKUS.
The Politikus by itself, apart from the Sophistês 260
Views of Plato on mensuration. Objects measured against each
other. Objects compared with a common standard. In each Art, the
purpose to be attained is the standard _ib._
Purpose in the Sophistês and Politikus is--To attain dialectic
aptitude. This is the standard of comparison whereby to judge
whether the means employed are suitable 261
Plato's defence of the Politikus against critics. Necessity that
the critic shall declare explicitly what his standard of
comparison is 262
Comparison of Politikus with Protagoras, Phædon, Philêbus, &c.
_ib._
Definition of the statesman, or Governor. Scientific competence.
Sokratic point of departure. Procedure of Plato in subdividing
263
King during the Saturnian period, was of a breed superior to the
people--not so any longer 264
Distinction of causes Principal and Causes Auxiliary. The King is
the only Principal Cause, but his auxiliaries pretend to be
principal also 266
Plato does not admit the received classification of government. It
does not touch the point upon which all true distinction ought to
be founded--Scientific or Unscientific 267
Unscientific governments are counterfeits. Government by any
numerous body must be counterfeit. Government by the one
scientific man is the true government 268
Fixed laws, limiting the scientific Governor, are mischievous, as
they would be for the physician and the steersman. Absurdity of
determining medical practice by laws, and presuming every one to
know it 269
Government by fixed laws is better than lawless government by
unscientific men, but worse than lawless government by scientific
men. It is a second-best _ib._
Comparison of unscientific governments. The one despot is the
worse. Democracy is the least bad, because it is least of a
government 270
The true governor distinguished from the General, the Rhetor, &c.
They are all properly his subordinates and auxiliaries 271