Plato and the Other Companions of Sokrates, 3rd ed. Volume 4 — Plato — John Shaqi
Plato and the Other Companions of Sokrates, 3rd ed. Volume 4
Plato · en
First formation of the Platonic city--how brought about:
difficult, but not impossible 78
The city thus formed will last long, but not for ever. After a
certain time, it will begin to degenerate. Stages of its
degeneracy _ib._
1. Timocracy and the timocratical individual. 2 Oligarchy, and the
oligarchical individual 79
3. Democracy, and the democratical individual 80
4. Passage from democracy to despotism. Character of the despotic
city 81
Despotic individual corresponding to that city 82
The city has thus passed by four stages, from best to worse.
Question--How are Happiness and Misery apportioned among them?
_ib._
Misery of the despotised city 83
Supreme Misery of the despotising individual _ib._
Conclusion--The Model city and the individual corresponding to it,
are the happiest of all--That which is farthest removed from it,
is the most miserable of all 84
The Just Man is happy in and through his Justice, however he may
be treated by others. The Unjust Man, miserable 84
Other arguments proving the same conclusion--Pleasures of
Intelligence are the best of all pleasures _ib._
They are the only pleasures completely true and pure. Comparison
of pleasure and pain with neutrality. Prevalent illusions 86
Most men know nothing of true and pure pleasure. Simile of the
Kosmos--Absolute height and depth 87
Nourishment of the mind partakes more of real essence than
nourishment of the body--Replenishment of the mind imparts fuller
pleasure than replenishment of the body 88
Comparative worthlessness of the pleasures of Appetite and
Ambition, when measured against those of Intelligence 89
The Just Man will be happy from his justice--He will look only to
the good order of his own mind--He will stand aloof from public
affairs, in cities as now constituted 90
Tenth Book--Censure of the poets is renewed--Mischiefs of
imitation generally, as deceptive--Imitation from imitation 91
Censure of Homer--He is falsely extolled as educator of the
Hellenic world. He and other poets only deceive their hearers 92
The poet chiefly appeals to emotions--Mischiefs of such eloquent
appeals, as disturbing the rational government of the mind
_ib._
Ancient quarrel between philosophy and poetry--Plato fights for
philosophy, though his feelings are strongly enlisted for poetry
93
Immortality of the soul affirmed and sustained by argument--Total
number of souls always the same _ib._
Recapitulation--The Just Man will be happy, both from his justice
and from its consequences, both here and hereafter 94
CHAPTER XXXVI.
REPUBLIC--REMARKS ON ITS MAIN THESIS.
Summary of the preceding chapter 95
Title of the Republic, of ancient date, but only a partial
indication of its contents 96
Parallelism between the Commonwealth and the Individual 96
Each of them a whole, composed of parts distinct in function and
unequal in merit 97