Platonism in English poetry of the sixteenth and seventeenth centuries — Plato — John Shaqi
Platonism in English poetry of the sixteenth and seventeenth centuries
Plato · en
“But in a body, which doth freely yeeld
His partes to reasons rule obedient,
And letteth her that ought the scepter weeld,
All happy peace and goodly government
Is setled there in sure establishment;
There _Alma_ like a virgin Queene most bright,
Doth florish in all beautie excellent:
And to her guestes doth bounteous banket dight,
Attempred goodly well for health and for delight.
(II. xi. 2.)
After this examination of Spenser’s ideals of holiness and temperance,
it is clear why Platonism as a system of ethics is absent in the
remaining books of the “Faerie Queene.” Spenser’s avowed aim in his poem
was “to fashion a gentleman or noble person in vertuous and gentle
discipline.” Since he conceives of life as a constant warfare with
inward and outward foes, his method of presenting his thought is to send
each virtue on a journey during which it is to perfect itself by
overcoming the vices to whose assaults it is especially liable. This
plan is carefully followed in the first two books. The allegorical
scheme is unbroken; the personages encountered by the Knights are
objectified states of their own spiritual consciousness. In the
remaining books, however, the allegorical scheme has well-nigh broken
down; and the poetic method is that of the romantic epic of adventure in
the manner of Ariosto. This change was due very largely to the fact that
after Spenser had completed his first two books he had exhausted the
ethical teachings of Plato; and when he went on to his remaining books,
he passed out of the sphere of virtue as taught by Plato into an
essentially different realm of thought in which the graces of courtly
accomplishment were dignified as virtues. He tried to treat these later
virtues of chastity, friendship, justice, courtesy, and constancy as if
they were coördinate with the virtues of holiness and temperance. But
they fall into a distinct class by themselves. They are the ideals of
conduct to be followed when man is acting in his purely social capacity
as a member of society. They may be dignified as virtues, but can never
be coördinate with the Platonic conception of virtue, which conceives of
it not as an outward act, but as the very health of the soul when
realizing, unhampered by any disturbing influences, its native impulses
toward the good.
The difference between these two conceptions is strikingly illustrated
by a comparison of Spenser’s idea of justice with the Platonic notion.
According to the English poet, justice is purely retributive, a
dispensing of reward and punishment. The education of the Knight of
Justice, Arthegal, by Astræa, is thus described:
“There she him taught to weigh both right and wrong
In equall ballance with due recompence,
And equitie to measure out along,
According to the line of conscience,
When so it needs with rigour to dispence.”