The philosophical and mathematical commentaries of Proclus on the first book of Euclid's elements (Vol. 1 of 2) : $b To which are added, A history of the restoration of Platonic theology, by the latter Platonists: And a translation from the Greek of Proclus's Theological elements — Plato — John Shaqi
The philosophical and mathematical commentaries of Proclus on the first book of Euclid's elements (Vol. 1 of 2) : $b To which are added, A history of the restoration of Platonic theology, by the latter Platonists: And a translation from the Greek of Proclus's Theological elements
Plato · en
Those things are said to be _essentially_ predicated; first,
when the predicate is not only total, but constitutes the essence
of the subject; instances of this kind are, animal of man; tree of
the plantain; a line of a triangle; for a triangle is that which is
contained under three right-lines. But here we must observe, that
not every total predicate is an essential one; thus, whiteness is
predicated of every swan, because it is inherent in every swan, and at
every instant of time; but because whiteness does not constitute the
essence of a swan, it is not essentially predicated; and this, first,
is one of the modes of essential predication of the greatest importance
in demonstration. The second mode is of accidents, in the definition
of which their common subject is applied: thus, a line is essentially
inherent in rectitude, because in its geometrical definition, a line
is adopted; for rectitude is no other than a measure, equally extended
between the points of a line. In the same manner, imparity is contained
in number; for what is that which is odd, but a number divided into
unequal parts? Thus, virtues are resident in the soul, because, in
their definition, either some part of the soul, or some one of its
powers, is always applied. The third mode of essential predicates
pertains to accidents which are inseparably contained in some
particular subject, so as to exclude a prior existence in any other
subject; such as colour in superficies. The fourth mode is of things
neither contained in another, nor predicated of others; and such are
all individuals, as Callias, Socrates, Plato. Causes are likewise said
to exist substantially, which operate neither from accident nor
fortune.
Thus, digging up the ground for the purposes of agriculture, may be the
cause of discovering a treasure, but it is only an accidental one. But
the death of Socrates, in despite of vigilance, is not the result of a
fortuitous cause, but of an essential one, viz. the operation of poison.
9. These posterior significations of essential predicates are added
more for the sake of ornament than use; but the two former have a
necessary existence, since they cannot but exist in the definition of
names which predicate the essence of a thing, and in subjects which are
so entirely the support of accidents, that they are always applied in
their definition. But it is a doubt with some, whether those accidents
are necessary, which cannot be defined independent of their common
subject? To this we answer, that no such accident can, from its nature,
be contained in every individual of any species; for curvature is not
contained in every line; nor imparity in every number; from whence we
infer, that neither is curvature necessarily existent in a line, nor
parity in number. The truth of this is evident from considering these
accidents abstracted from their subjects; for then we shall perceive
that a line may exist without curvature, and number without imparity.