Many illustrations of this part of the Republic may be found in modern
Politics and in daily life. For among ourselves, too, there have been two
sorts of Politicians or Statesmen, whose eyesight has become disordered in
two different ways. First, there have been great men who, in the language
of Burke, 'have been too much given to general maxims,' who, like J. S.
Mill or Burke himself, have been theorists or philosophers before they
were politicians, or who, having been students of history, have allowed
some great historical parallel, such as the English Revolution of 1688, or
possibly Athenian democracy or Roman Imperialism, to be the medium through
which they viewed contemporary events. Or perhaps the long projecting
shadow of some existing institution may have darkened their vision. The
Church of the future, the Commonwealth of the future, the Society of the
future, have so absorbed their minds, that they are unable to see in their
true proportions the Politics of to-day. They have been intoxicated with
great ideas, such as liberty, or equality, or the greatest happiness of
the greatest number, or the brotherhood of humanity, and they no longer
care to consider how these ideas must be limited in practice or harmonized
with the conditions of human life. They are full of light, but the light
to them has become only a sort of luminous mist or blindness. Almost every
one has known some enthusiastic half-educated person, who sees everything
at false distances, and in erroneous proportions.
With this disorder of eyesight may be contrasted another--of those who see
not far into the distance, but what is near only; who have been engaged
all their lives in a trade or a profession; who are limited to a set or
sect of their own. Men of this kind {cxiv} have no universal except their
own interests or the interests of their class, no principle but the
opinion of persons like themselves, no knowledge of affairs beyond what
they pick up in the streets or at their club. Suppose them to be sent into
a larger world, to undertake some higher calling, from being tradesmen to
turn generals or politicians, from being schoolmasters to become
philosophers:--or imagine them on a sudden to receive an inward light
which reveals to them for the first time in their lives a higher idea of
God and the existence of a spiritual world, by this sudden conversion or
change is not their daily life likely to be upset; and on the other hand
will not many of their old prejudices and narrownesses still adhere to
them long after they have begun to take a more comprehensive view of human
things? From familiar examples like these we may learn what Plato meant by
the eyesight which is liable to two kinds of disorders.