The works of Plato (Vol. 1 of 6) : $b A new and literal version chiefly from the text of Stallbaum
Plato · en
calamity prostrate in the command of a ship? Clearly not a private
person, for the private person is always prostrate; as therefore no one
can throw down a man who is lying on the ground, but sometimes one may
throw down one who is standing upright, so as to make him lie on the
ground, but not one already lying there, so an irresistible calamity may
sometimes prostrate a skilful man, but never one who is always
unskilful; and a violent storm bursting on a pilot may make his skill of
no avail, and a bad season befalling a farmer may make his skill of no
avail, and the same with a physician: for it befals a good man to become
evil, as is also testified by another poet, who says, ‘A good man is
sometimes evil, and sometimes good:’ but it does not befal the evil to
become so, but he must needs always be so. So that when an irresistible
calamity prostrates a skilful, wise, and good man, it is not possible
for him not to be evil; but you say, Pittacus, that it is difficult to
be good; but the difficulty is to become good, though it is possible,
but impossible to be so. 86. ‘For every man who fares well is good, but
evil if he fares ill.’ What then is faring well with respect to
literature? and what makes a man good in literature? Clearly the being
instructed in it. What faring well makes a good physician? Clearly the
being instructed in the art of curing the sick. ‘And evil if he fares
ill.’ Who then would become an evil physician? Clearly he to whom it
happens first to be a physician, and then a good physician; for he may
become an evil physician. But we who are ignorant of the medical art,
can never by faring ill become either physicians, or builders, or any
thing else of the kind; but whoever cannot become a physician by faring
ill, clearly cannot become an evil physician. Thus also a good man may
sometime or other become evil, either from length of time, or labour, or
disease, or some other accident, for this alone is a faring ill, to be
deprived of knowledge, but the evil man can never become evil, for he is
always so; but if he is to become evil, it is necessary for him first to
become good. So that this part of the ode tends to this, that it is not
possible to be a good man, so as to continue good; but that it is
possible to become good, and for the same person to become evil: ‘and
they are for the longest time best whom the gods love.’