The works of Plato (Vol. 1 of 6) : $b A new and literal version chiefly from the text of Stallbaum
Plato · en
120. “These points, then, being established,” I said, “Prodicus and
Hippias, let Protagoras here defend himself and shew us how his first
answer is correct, no, not quite the first, for he then said, that there
being five parts of virtue, no one of them was like any other, but that
each had a peculiar function of its own. I do not however mean this, but
what he said afterwards. For afterwards he said, that four of them very
much resembled each other, but that one was altogether different from
the rest, namely courage. And he said I should know it by the following
proof. ‘You will find men, Socrates, who are most unholy, most unjust,
most intemperate, and most ignorant, who are yet most courageous; by
which you will know that courage differs much from the other parts of
virtue.’ And I indeed, at the moment, was very much astonished at the
answer, and I have been still more so since I have discussed these
things with you. I therefore asked him if he meant that courageous men
are bold? He said he did, and ready to rush headlong. 121. Do you
remember, Protagoras,” said I, “that you gave this answer?”
He admitted it.
“Come then,” said I, “tell us on what you say the courageous are ready
to rush headlong? Is it on the same things as cowards?”
He said not.
“On different things, therefore.”
“Yes,” he replied.
“But whether do cowards attempt things which they can venture on with
confidence, but the courageous on such as are dreadful?”
“It is said so, Socrates, by the generality of men.”
“You say truly,” I replied. “I do not, however, ask this: but on what do
you say courageous men are ready to rush headlong, on dreadful things,
thinking that they are dreadful, or on such as are not dreadful?”
“But this,” he said, “in the arguments which you just now used, was
shewn to be impossible.”
“And in this,” I replied, “you say truly. So that if this point was
proved correctly, no one attempts things which he considers to be
dreadful, since to be overcome by one’s-self was found to be ignorance.”
He admitted it.
“All men, however, attempt things in which they have confidence, both
the cowardly and the courageous, and thus both the cowardly and the
courageous attempt the same things.”
122. “But indeed, Socrates,” said he, “the things which the cowardly and
the courageous attempt are quite contrary to each other; for instance,
the latter are willing to engage in war, but the former are unwilling.”
“Whether,” said I, “is it honourable to engage in it, or base?”
“Honourable,” he replied.
“If, therefore, it is honourable, have we not already admitted that it
is good, for we have admitted that all honourable actions are good.”
“You say truly, and I am always of this opinion.”
“Right,” said I. “But which of the two do you say are unwilling to
engage in war, though it is honourable and good?”
“Cowards,” he replied.
“If therefore,” said I, “it be honourable and good, is it not also
pleasant?”
“That has been granted,” he said.