Asma bint Marwan: Raat Ka Qatl, Tooti Hui Sanad, Aur Ulama Ke Do Sutoon
Ibn Ishaq, Waqidi aur Ibn Saad likhte hain ke Madina ki ek shaira apne bachon ke darmiyan sote mein qatl ki gayi — aur kaha gaya ke us par do bakriyan bhi sar nahin takrayengi. Sihah Sitta mein uska naam tak nahin. Ek sutoon isse gharha hua kehta hai, doosra tareekh. Dono ke matan aamne samne.
By John Shaqi · July 23, 2026 · 15 min read

Fajr Se Pehle Ek Sawal
Ramzan ka aakhri hafta hai, Madina ki taraf hijrat ke unnees mahine baad — jaisa ke ek qadeem kitab ne iski tareekh darj ki hai. Banu Khatma ka ek shakhs raat ke andhere mein sheher ki galiyon se guzarta hai aur ek aise ghar mein dakhil hota hai jahan ek aurat soyi hui hai, uske bache uske gird hain, aur ek sheerkhwar bacha uske seene se laga hua hai. Subah hone tak woh aurat qatl ho chuki hai. Woh shakhs Fajr ki namaz mein shareek hota hai. Ek sawal poocha jata hai. Ek jawab diya jata hai. Aur do bakriyon ke baare mein ek jumla hamesha ke liye tareekh ki kitabon mein dakhil ho jata hai.
Kitabon mein us aurat ka naam Asma bint Marwan likha hai — Banu Umayya bin Zaid ki ek shaira, jo Banu Khatma ke Yazid bin Zaid ki biwi thi. Uska qissa Paighambar-e-Islam ki qadeem tareen seeraton mein maujood hai jo doosri aur teesri sadi Hijri mein likhi gayin. Lekin yeh qissa Sahih Bukhari mein nahin hai. Sahih Muslim mein nahin hai. Aur ek hazaar saal se zyada arse se Musalman ulama ke do sutoon is baat par ikhtilaf karte aa rahe hain ke aaya yeh waqia sire se hua bhi tha ya nahin.
Continue Reading
Continue reading this article
Sign in free to read in full. Become a member to join the discussion without limits.
Sign in free to read →- ✓Read every article
- ✓Comment and reply (up to 100 words, 10/month)
- ✓Browse the community
- ✓Reader badge