John Shaqi

Ka'b bin Ashraf ka Qatl: Bukhari 4037 aur "Kaho, jo chaho" ki Ijazat

Sahih Bukhari 4037 mein mehfooz ek raat: Ka'b bin Ashraf ka qatl, "kaho jo chaho" ki ijazat, aur razai bhai ka kirdar. Ek taraf Bukhari aur Ibn Ishaq ke mutoon, doosri taraf ulama ke difai dalail — dono column jyon ke tyon. Faisla aap ka.

By John Shaqi · July 24, 2026 · 15 min read

Ka'b bin Ashraf ka Qatl: Bukhari 4037 aur "Kaho, jo chaho" ki Ijazat

Aadhi Raat ki Dastak

Madina, Rabi-ul-Awwal, hijrat ka teesra saal. Chandni raat hai. Paanch aadmi shehar se nikal kar bahar ek qile ki taraf ja rahe hain. In mein se ek, Abu Naila, usi shakhs ka razai bhai hai jis se milne woh ja rahe hain — dono ne ek hi aurat ka doodh piya tha. Qile ke andar jo shakhs hai woh ek qabile ka sardar, Arab ka mashhoor shair, aur ilaqe ke ameer tareen logon mein se hai. Us ki nayi shadi hui hai. Jab neeche se awaz aati hai to us ki biwi chadar ka kinara pakar leti hai aur kehti hai ke mujhe is awaz mein jaise khoon tapakne ki awaz sunai de rahi hai. Woh jawab deta hai ke bulane wala mera bhai hai, aur shareef aadmi ko raat ke waqt neze ke waar ke liye bhi bulaya jaye to woh inkaar nahin karta. Woh neeche utarta hai. Ghari bhar mein us ka qissa tamaam ho jata hai. Yeh saari tafseel kisi mukhalif muarrikh ke qalam se nahin aayi. Yeh Sahih Bukhari mein darj hai — woh kitab jise Ahl-e-Sunnat Quran ke baad rooe zameen ki sahih tareen kitab maante hain.

Yeh mazmoon kisi mazhab ka mazaq nahin urata. Hum wohi karenge jo hum hamesha karte hain: kitabein kholenge, mutoon ko jyon ka tyon pesh karenge, aur teen sawal poochenge. Bukhari 4037 asal mein kya kehti hai? Qatl ki wajah khud matan mein kya bayan hui hai? Aur ulama ne chaudah sadiyon mein is waqie ka difa kin dalail se kiya hai? Dono taraf ka mawad aap ke samne rakha jayega. Faisla, hamesha ki tarah, aap ka hai.

Continue Reading

Continue reading this article

Sign in free to read in full. Become a member to join the discussion without limits.

Sign in free to read →
Reader$0/mo
  • Read every article
  • Comment and reply (up to 100 words, 10/month)
  • Browse the community
  • Reader badge
Join as Reader
Scholar$8/mo
  • Everything in Writer
  • Scholar badge
  • Featured in the community
Join as Scholar