Kinana ibn al-Rabi: Khaybar ka Khazana, Seene par Aag, aur Sanad ka Sawal
Ibn Ishaq likhte hain ke Khaybar ke khazane ke sawal par Kinana ibn al-Rabi ke seene par aag jalai gayi aur phir gardan maari gayi — magar is riwayat ki koi sanad nahi, aur Sahih Bukhari mein aag se azaab ki sareeh mumaniat maujood hai. Dono taraf ke mutoon jyun ke tyun paish hain; faisla qaari ka hai.
By John Shaqi · July 24, 2026 · 15 min read

Ek Shakhs ke Seene par Aag
Muharram 7 Hijri — May 628 CE. Shumali Arab ki sab se maaldar Yahudi basti Khaybar ke qilay yake baad deegre fatah ho chuke hain. Qaidiyon mein ek naujawan sardar khada hai: Kinana ibn al-Rabi ibn Abi al-Huqayq — Banu Nadir ke mashhoor khazane ka ameen aur naujawan Safiyya bint Huyayy ka shohar. Usay Paighambar-e-Islam ke samne laya jata hai aur ek hi sawal hota hai: khazana kahan hai? Is ke baad jo kuch hua, woh seerat ki sab se purani kitab mein chand satron mein darj hai — aur inhi chand satron mein ek khandar hai, ek dafan khazana hai, ek seene par jalti aag hai, aur ek talwar. Barah sadiyon se yeh chand satrein do bilkul mukhtalif tareeqon se parhi ja rahi hain.
Yeh mazmoon kisi mazhab ka mazaq nahi udata. Hum wohi karenge jo hamesha karte hain: kitabein kholenge, mutoon jyun ke tyun paish karenge, aur teen sawal poochhenge: Ibn Ishaq aur Tabari ne asal mein kya likha? Kya yeh riwayat muhaddiseen ke miyar par poori utarti hai? Aur khud Musalman fuqaha ne is waqiye se kya qanooni nataij nikale? Faisla, hamesha ki tarah, aap ka hai.
Continue Reading
Continue reading this article
Sign in free to read in full. Become a member to join the discussion without limits.
Sign in free to read →- ✓Read every article
- ✓Comment and reply (up to 100 words, 10/month)
- ✓Browse the community
- ✓Reader badge