A history of criticism and literary taste in Europe, from the earliest texts to the present day. Volume 3 (of 3), Modern criticismSaintsbury, George
History
A history of criticism and literary taste in Europe, from the earliest texts to the present day. Volume 3 (of 3), Modern criticism
Saintsbury, George
Criticism -- History; Literature -- History and criticism; Literature, Medieval
The chief ferment, however, of German poetic and criticism of a kind did
not come till towards the middle of the century and when the Thirty
Years’ War was dying down (though it is thought to have been to some
extent determined by the sojourning of at least one German of
letters[17] in England quite in the earlier stage of that convulsion):
and it took final colour from French rather than from English, partly in
the form of Pléiade and Louis Treize _ampullæ_, partly in that of
“correctness” (as far as the Germans could reach it) _à la_ Boileau. The
earlier inquirers, such as Schottel, Zesen, Buchner, were painful and
estimable rhetoricians, anxious to get German into good scholastic ways.
Schottel, in his _Teutsche Sprachkunst_[18] and other works, is quite of
the old fashion in compounding rhetoric-poetic-composition books with
dictionary. Zesen’s _Hochdeutscher Helikon_[19] is an extremely fat
little book, the component parts of which are separately paged, and
sometimes not paged at all, and which discusses with the utmost care the
terms of the art in metre, rhyme, stanza-building, &c., gives rhyming
dictionaries first of masculine then of feminine rhymes, supplies
plenteous example-verse, and finishes with a _De Poetica_ of a more
general kind. Augustine Buchner[20] is still older-fashioned, and
reminds one of the sixteenth-century Italians in his little tractate on
the office and aim of poetry, its kinds, ornaments, &c.
[Sidenote: _Weise, Wernicke, Werenfels, &c._]
These are hardly at all critical; they are rhetorical-preceptist. But
the later men, such as Weise, Wernicke, and Werenfels, exhibit the
revolt against the school of conceit and bombast which in the later part
of the seventeenth century radiates from France all over Europe.
Christian Weise, _Professor Poeseos_ as he called himself, degrades
Poetry in his _Curiose Gedanken neben Deutschen Versen_ (1691) to the
position of a mere _ancilla_ of Rhetoric, and seems to have anticipated
Shaftesbury in making “ridicule the test of truth.” His namesake,
Wernicke, in the “Ad Lectorem” of his _Poetische Versuche_,[21] extols
Longinus, and makes “polite” remarks on Lohenstein and Hoffmanswaldau.
But _the_ German manifesto against the florid is the _Dissertatio de
Meteoris Orationis_ appended to the _De Logomachiis Eruditorum_ of
Samuel Werenfels, which appeared at Amsterdam within the eighteenth
century,[22] dedicated to no less a person than Gilbert Burnet, but
presents the matter of two theses composed fourteen and ten years
earlier. The _De Logomachiis_ itself has a certain interest for us, as
it hits among other things at frivolous and verbal criticism; but the
_Dissertatio_ is all ours. Werenfels, as usual basing himself upon
Longinus, without the slightest suspicion that he will be undone by his
reliance, distinguishes between ὕψηλα and μετέωρα—our old friends the
True and the False Sublime. He admits the importance of Imagination, but
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account