Animal intelligence: Experimental studiesThorndike, Edward L. (Edward Lee)
Science
Animal intelligence: Experimental studies
Thorndike, Edward L. (Edward Lee)
Animal intelligence; Psychology, Comparative
Some sheep were being driven on board ship one at a time. In the course
of their progress they had to jump over a hurdle. On this being removed
before all had passed it, the next sheep was seen to jump as if to get
over a hurdle, and so on for five or six, apparently sure evidence that
they imitated the action, each of the one in front. Now, it is again
possible that among gregarious animals there may be elaborate connections
in the nervous system which allow the sight of certain particular acts in
another animal to arouse the innervation leading to those acts, but that
these connections are _limited_. The reactions on this view are specific
responses to definite signals, comparable to any other instinctive or
associational reaction. The sheep jumps when he sees the other sheep
jump, not because of a general ability to do what he sees done, but
because he is furnished with the instinct to jump at such a sight, or
because his experience of following the flock over boulders and brooks
and walls has got him into the habit of jumping at the spot where he
sees one ahead of him jump; and so he jumps even though no obstacle be
in his way. If due to instinct, the only peculiarity of such a reaction
would be that the sense-impression calling forth the act would be the
same act as done by another. If due to experience, there would be an
exact correspondence to the frequent acts called forth _originally_ by
several elements in a sense-impression, one of which is essential, and
done _afterwards_ when only the _non-essentials_ are present. These two
possibilities have not been sufficiently realized, yet they may contain
the truth. On the other hand, these limited acts may be the primitive,
sporadic beginnings of the general imitative faculty which we find in
man. To this general faculty we may now turn, having cleared away some of
the more doubtful phenomena which have shared its name.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account