Charles Dickens: A critical studyChesterton, G. K. (Gilbert Keith)
General
Charles Dickens: A critical study
Chesterton, G. K. (Gilbert Keith)
Dickens, Charles, 1812-1870
As our world advances through history towards its present epoch, it
becomes more specialist, less democratic, and folklore turns gradually
into fiction. But it is only slowly that the old elfin fire fades into
the light of common realism. For ages after our characters have dressed
up in the clothes of mortals they betray the blood of the gods. Even
our phraseology is full of relics of this. When a modern novel is
devoted to the bewilderments of a weak young clerk who cannot decide
which woman he wants to marry, or which new religion he believes in,
we still give this knock-kneed cad the name of “the hero”--the name
which is the crown of Achilles. The popular preference for a story
with “a happy ending” is not, or at least was not, a mere sweet-stuff
optimism; it is the remains of the old idea of the triumph of the
dragon-slayer, the ultimate apotheosis of the man beloved of heaven.
But there is another and more intangible trace of this fading
supernaturalism--a trace very vivid to the reader, but very elusive
to the critic. It is a certain air of endlessness in the episodes,
even in the shortest episodes--a sense that, although we leave them,
they still go on. Our modern attraction to short stories is not an
accident of form; it is the sign of a real sense of fleetingness and
fragility; it means that existence is only an impression, and, perhaps,
only an illusion. A short story of to-day has the air of a dream; it
has the irrevocable beauty of a falsehood; we get a glimpse of grey
streets of London or red plains of India, as in an opium vision; we
see people,--arresting people, with fiery and appealing faces. But
when the story is ended, the people are ended. We have no instinct
of anything ultimate and enduring behind the episodes. The moderns,
in a word, describe life in short stories because they are possessed
with the sentiment that life itself is an uncommonly short story,
and perhaps not a true one. But in this elder literature, even in the
comic literature (indeed, especially in the comic literature), the
reverse is true. The characters are felt to be fixed things of which
we have fleeting glimpses; that is, they are felt to be divine. Uncle
Toby is talking for ever, as the elves are dancing for ever. We feel
that whenever we hammer on the house of Falstaff, Falstaff will be
at home. We feel it as a Pagan would feel that, if a cry broke the
silence after ages of unbelief, Apollo would still be listening in his
temple. These writers may tell short stories, but we feel they are only
parts of a long story. And herein lies the peculiar significance, the
peculiar sacredness even, of penny dreadfuls and the common printed
matter made for our errand-boys. Here in dim and desperate forms, under
the ban of our base culture, stormed at by silly magistrates, sneered
at by silly schoolmasters,--here is the old popular literature still
popular; here is the unmistakable voluminousness, the thousand and one
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account