In spite of appearances to the contrary, Dürer was, as I have said,
unimaginative. He needed the written word or another's idea as a
guide; he never dreamt of an Art that could be beautiful without a
"mission"--he never "created." Try to realise for a moment that
throughout his work--in accordance with the conception of his age--he
mixes purely modern dress with biblical and classical representation, as
if our Leightons, Tademas, Poynters, were to introduce crinolines,
bustles, or "empire" gowns amongst Venuses and Apollos. In the pathetic
"Deposition from the Cross" the Magdalen is just a "modern" Nuremberg
damsel, and the Virgin's headwrap is slung as the northern housewife
wore it, and not like an Oriental woman's; Joseph of Arimathea and
Nicodemus are clad as Nuremberg burghers, and only in the figure of John
does he make concession to the traditional "classic" garment. Such an
anachronistic medley could only appear logical so long as the religious
spirit and the convictions of the majority were at one. I dare scarcely
hint at, much less describe, the feelings that would be stirred in you
if a modern painter represented the Crucifixion with Nicodemus and the
man from Arimathea in frock-coats, Mary and the Magdalen in "walking
costume," and a company of Horse-guards in attendance. The abyss of over
four centuries divides us from Dürer; my suggestion sounds blasphemous
almost, yet it is a thought based on fact and worthy of most careful
note.
Owing to a convention--then active, now defunct--Dürer grasped the hands
of all the living, bade them stop and think. Not one of those who beheld
his work could pass by without feeling a call of sympathy and
understanding. "Everyman" Dürer!--that is his grandeur. To this the
artists added their appreciation; what he did was not only _truly_ done,
but on the testimony of all his brothers in Art _well_ done. So with
graver, pen, and brush he gave his world the outlines of Belief. In his
pictures the illiterate saw, as by revelation, that which they could not
read, and the literate, the literati--Erasmus, Pirkheimer, Melanchthon
amongst the most prominent--saw the excellence of the manner of his
revelations.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account