Goethe's literary essays : $b A selection in EnglishGoethe, Johann Wolfgang von
History
Goethe's literary essays : $b A selection in English
Goethe, Johann Wolfgang von
Art; Literature -- History and criticism
The arts themselves, as well as their subordinate forms, are closely
related to each other, and have a certain tendency to unite, and even
lose themselves in each other; but herein lies the duty, the merit,
the dignity of the true artist, that he knows how to separate that
department in which he labors from the others, and, so far as may be,
isolates it.
It has been noticed that all plastic art tends towards painting, all
poetry to the drama; and this may furnish the text for some important
observations hereafter.
The genuine, law-giving artist strives after artistic truth;
the lawless, following a blind instinct, after an appearance of
naturalness. The former leads to the highest pinnacle of art, the
latter to its lowest step.
This is no less true of the separate arts than of art in general.
The sculptor must think and feel differently from the painter, and
must go to work differently to execute a work in relief from what he
would do with a round and complete piece of statuary. When the work
in low relief came to be brought out more and more, and by degrees
parts and figures were brought out from the ground, at last buildings
and landscapes admitted, and thus a work produced, half picture half
puppet-show, true art was on the decline; and it is to be deplored
that excellent artists have in more recent times taken this direction.
Whenever we enunciate hereafter such maxims as we esteem true, we
shall feel a real desire, since these maxims are drawn from works of
art, to have them practically tested by artists. How seldom does one
man agree with another concerning a theoretic principle; the practical
and immediately useful is far more quickly adopted. How often do we
see artists at a loss in the choice of a subject, in the general
composition, according to their rules of art, in the arrangement of
details; the painter doubtful about the choice of his colors! Then is
the time to make trial of a principle; then will it be easier to decide
the question,--Do we by its aid come nearer to the great models, and
all that we love and prize, or does it forsake us in the empirical
confusion of an experiment not thoroughly thought out?
If such maxims should prove useful in forwarding the culture of
artists, in guiding them among difficulties, they will also aid the
understanding, true estimation, and criticism of ancient and modern
works, and, _vice versa_, will again be discovered in the examination
of these works. This is all the more necessary, since, in spite of the
universally acknowledged excellence of the antique, individuals as well
as whole nations have in modern times often misconceived those very
things wherein the highest excellence of those works lies.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account