Goethe's literary essays : $b A selection in EnglishGoethe, Johann Wolfgang von
History
Goethe's literary essays : $b A selection in English
Goethe, Johann Wolfgang von
Art; Literature -- History and criticism
An exact scrutiny of these will be the best means of securing us
against this evil. Let us now take, as an example, the usual course of
proceeding of the amateur in plastic art, in order to make it evident
how necessary a thorough criticism of ancient as well as modern works
is, if we would profit by it.
No person of a fine natural perception, however uncultivated, can
see even an imperfect, incorrect cast of a fine ancient work without
being greatly impressed by it; for such a representation still gives
the idea, the simplicity and greatness of the form, in a word, the
general notion at least, such as a man of imperfect sight would see at
a distance.
We may often observe how a strong inclination towards art is awakened
through such an imperfect reproduction. But the effect is analogous
to the object that caused it, and such beginners in art are rather
impressed with a blind and indefinite feeling than with the true worth
and significance of the object itself. It is such as these who are the
authors of the theory that a too curious critical examination destroys
our pleasure, and who decry and resist the investigation of details.
But when by degrees their experience and knowledge become wider, and
a sharper cast in place of the imperfect one, or an original instead
of a cast comes under their observation, their satisfaction increases
with their insight, and continually advances when at last the originals
themselves, the perfect originals, become known to them.
We are not deterred by the labyrinth of thorough examination, when the
details are of equal perfection with the whole work. Nay, we learn
that we are able to appreciate the perfect, just so far as we are in
a condition to discern the defective: to distinguish the restored
from the original parts, the copy from the model, to contemplate in
the smallest fragments the scattered excellence of the whole, is a
satisfaction that belongs only to the perfect connoisseur; and there is
a wide difference between the contemplation of an imperfect whole with
groping sense, and the seeing and seizing, with clear eye, of a perfect
one.
He who devotes himself to any department of knowledge should aim at the
highest. Insight and Practice follow widely different paths, for in
the practical each one soon becomes aware that only a certain measure
of power is meted to him. But a far greater number of men are capable
of knowledge, of insight; we may even say that every man is so who
can deny himself, subordinate himself to objects, and does not strive
with a rigid and narrow individuality to bring in himself and his poor
one-sidedness amid the highest works of nature and art.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account