Goethe's literary essays : $b A selection in English — John Shaqi
Goethe's literary essays : $b A selection in EnglishGoethe, Johann Wolfgang von
History
Goethe's literary essays : $b A selection in English
Goethe, Johann Wolfgang von
Art; Literature -- History and criticism
Here our friend hits the nail on the head; for in that very point where
he places me below Shakespeare do we stand below the ancients. And what
is it we advance concerning the ancients? Any talent, the development
of which is not favored by time and circumstances, and must on that
account work its way through a thousand obstacles, and get rid of a
thousand errors, must always be at a disadvantage, when compared with
a contemporary one that has the opportunity to cultivate itself with
facility and act to the extent of its capacity without opposition.
It often happens that people who are no longer young are able, out of
the fullness of their experience, to furnish an illustration that will
explain or strengthen an assertion; and this is my excuse for relating
the following anecdote. A practised diplomatist who had desired my
acquaintance, after the first interview, when he had had but little
opportunity of seeing or conversing with me, remarked to his friends:
“Voilà un homme qui a eu de grands chagrins!” These words set me to
thinking. The skilful physiognomist’s eye did not deceive him, only he
laid to the effect of suffering the phenomenon that should also have
been ascribed to opposition. An observant, straightforward German might
have said, “Here is a man who has had a very hard time of it.” Since,
then, the signs of past endurance and of persevering activity do not
disappear from the face, it is no wonder if all that remains of us
and our strivings should bear the same impress, and indicate, to the
attentive observer, a mode of being whose aim has been to preserve its
balance alike under circumstances of happiest development or narrowest
limitation, and to maintain the stubbornness, if it could not always
the highest dignity, of human existence.
But letting pass old and new, past and present, we may in general
assert that every artistic production places us in the same state of
mind the author was in. If that was clear and bright, we shall feel
free; if that was narrow, timid, or anxious, we shall feel limited in
the same proportion.
Upon reflection, we should add that this refers only to treatment.
Material and import do not enter into consideration. If we bear in mind
this principle, and look around in the world of art, we maintain that
every work will afford us pleasure which the artist himself produced
with ease and facility. What amateur does not rejoice in the possession
of a successful drawing or etching of our Chodowiecki? We see in them
such an immediate apprehension of nature, as we know it, that they
leave nothing to wish for. But he would not be able to go beyond his
mark and line, without losing all the advantage he derives from his
peculiar qualifications.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account