Irish ImpressionsChesterton, G. K. (Gilbert Keith)
History
Irish Impressions
Chesterton, G. K. (Gilbert Keith)
Ireland -- Civilization; Irish question
Celts, I feel more at home with the good if sometimes mad Christian
gentlemen of the Young Ireland movement, or even the Easter Rebellion.
I should feel more safe with Meagher of the Sword than with the
primitive Celt of the safety razor. The microscopic meanness of the
Mid-Victorian English writers, when they wrote about Irish patriots,
could see nothing but a very small joke in modern rebels thinking
themselves worthy to take the titles of antique kings. But the only
doubt I should have, if I had any, is whether the heathen kings were
worthy of the Christian rebels. I am much more sure of the heroism of
the modern Fenians than of the ancient ones.
Of the artistic side of the cult of the Celts I do not especially speak
here. And indeed its importance, especially to the Irish, may easily be
exaggerated. Mr W. B. Yeats long ago dissociated himself from a merely
racial theory of Irish poetry; and Mr W. B. Yeats thinks as hard as
he talks. I often entirely disagree with him; but I disagree far more
with the people who find him a poetical opiate, where I always find
him a logical stimulant. For the rest, Celticism in some aspects is
largely a conspiracy for leading the Englishman a dance, if it be a
fairy dance. I suspect that many names and announcements are printed
in Gaelic, not because Irishmen can read them, but because Englishmen
can’t. The other great modern mystic in Dublin, entertained us first by
telling an English lady present that she would never resist the Celtic
atmosphere, struggle how she might, but would soon be wandering in the
mountain mists with a fillet round her head; which fate had apparently
overtaken the son or nephew of an Anglican bishop who had strayed into
those parts. The English lady, whom I happen to know rather well, made
the characteristic announcement that she would go to Paris when she
felt it coming on. But it seemed to me that such drastic action was
hardly necessary, and that there was comparatively little cause for
alarm; seeing that the mountain mists certainly had not had that effect
on the people who happen to live in the mountains. I knew that the
poet knew, even better than I did, that Irish peasants do not wander
about in fillets, or indeed wander about at all, having plenty of much
better work to do. And since the Celtic atmosphere had no perceptible
effect on the Celts, I felt no alarm about its effect on the Saxons.
But the only thing involved, by way of an effect on the Saxons, was a
practical joke on the Saxons; which may, however, have lasted longer in
the case of the bishop’s son than it did in mine. Anyhow, I continued
to move about (like Atalanta in Calydon) with unchapleted hair, with
unfilleted cheek; and found a sufficient number of Irish people in the
same condition to prevent me from feeling shy. In a word, all that sort
of thing is simply the poet’s humour, especially his good humour, which
is of a golden and godlike sort. And a man would be very much misled by
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account