Medieval rhetoric and poetic to 1400 : $b Interpreted from representative worksBaldwin, Charles Sears
History
Medieval rhetoric and poetic to 1400 : $b Interpreted from representative works
Baldwin, Charles Sears
Literature, Medieval -- History and criticism; Poetics -- History -- To 1500; Rhetoric, Medieval
But now let us come to the point, that is the actual working
out. Let this working out be as follows: first, brief encomium
of the sayer or doer; then paraphrase of the chria itself; then
proof or explanation. For example, Isocrates said that the root
of education is bitter, but its fruit sweet: (1) encomium,
“Isocrates was wise,” and you will slightly develop this topic;
(2) chria, “said, etc.,” and you will not leave this bare, but
develop the significance; (3) proof, (a) direct, “the greatest
affairs are usually established through toil, and, once
established, bring happiness”; (b) by contrast, “those affairs
which succeed by chance require no toil and their conclusion
brings no happiness; quite the contrary with things that demand
our zeal”; (c) by illustration, “as the farmers who toil
ought to reap the fruit, so with speeches”; (d) by example,
“Demosthenes, who shut himself up in his room and labored much,
finally reaped his fruit, crowns and public proclamations.” (e)
You may also cite authority, as “Hesiod says, ‘Before virtue
the gods have put sweat’; and another poet says, ‘The gods
sell all good things for labor.’” (4) Last you will put an
exhortation to follow what was said or done.
So much for now; fuller instructions you will learn later.
PROVERB
A proverb is a summary saying, in a statement of general
application, dissuading from something or persuading toward
something, or showing what is the nature of each: dissuading,
as in that line “a counsellor should not sleep all night”;
persuading, as in the lines “he who flees poverty, Cyrnus,
must cast himself upon the monster-haunted deep and down steep
crags.” Or it does neither of these, but makes a declaration
concerning the nature of the thing: “Faring well undeservedly
is for the unintelligent the beginning of thinking ill.”
Again, some proverbs are true, others plausible; some simple,
others compound, others hyperbolic:
(1) true, such as “no one can find a life without pain”;
(2) plausible, such as “never have I asked what manner of man
takes pleasure in bad company, knowing that birds of a feather
flock together”;
(3) simple, such as “wealth may make men even benevolent”;
(4) compound, such as “no good comes of many rulers; let there
be one”;
(5) hyperbolic, such as “earth breeds nothing feebler than man.”
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account