On the Curability of Certain Forms of Insanity, Epilepsy, Catalepsy, and Hysteria in FemalesBrown, Isaac Baker
Science
On the Curability of Certain Forms of Insanity, Epilepsy, Catalepsy, and Hysteria in Females
Brown, Isaac Baker
Clitoridectomy
I hope to be able to show that a far more humane and effectual method is
that which I constantly practise, and for the last six or seven years
have openly and consistently advocated. Of course, from the very novelty
of these views, I have been met with many objections, such as unsexing
the female, preventing the normal excitement consequent on marital
intercourse, or actually, as some most absurdly and unphilosophically
assert, causing sterility: whereas my cases will show fact to be
directly converse to all these theories; and it is curious that a
physician for many years connected with one of our largest metropolitan
hospitals, and recognized as a standard writer on female diseases, has
in writing condemned my practice in not very measured terms, but is
himself constantly in the habit of trying to subdue this peripheral
irritation by continual application of the strongest caustics to the
seat of the irritation; thereby showing that he recognizes the source of
evil, but is not yet able to see that a superficial sore will not
destroy deep-seated nerve irritation. It wants, I imagine, little
argument to prove that so far from this practice being beneficial, it is
likely, by causing increased irritation, to be positively injurious.
Other practitioners follow Dr. Brown-Séquard’s plan of applying actual
cautery to the irritant nerve; and many more have advanced as far as the
operation—which I was formerly in the habit of practising—subcutaneous
division of the nerve. I have long abandoned this method as being no
more certain in its effect than kindred operations on various branches
of the fifth nerve for tic doloureux.
Another objection has been made that several of my cases have not been
permanently cured, but have had relapses in a few weeks or months. This
must necessarily be so with all new methods of treatment; but each such
case is of incalculable importance, as teaching me to exclude any but
temporary hope of relief to some, while to others I can speak all the
more positively as to their ultimate permanent recovery.
Experience seems to teach that in those patients whose brains have been
so weakened by long-continued peripheral excitement, causing frequent
and increasing losses of nerve force, there is not sufficient mental
power to enable them to control any less powerful irritation of smaller
branches of the pudic nerve, than that removed by operation.
This lesser excitement acts chiefly, I imagine, by preventing
restoration, in the same manner as a drunkard whose brain is weakened by
long indulgence in his baneful habit cannot resist temptation, but is,
however, affected by much smaller quantities of stimuli, than when
strong, he was able to take.
A striking instance of this kind occurred to me last year.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account