Plutarch on the Delay of the Divine JusticePlutarch
Philosophy
Plutarch on the Delay of the Divine Justice
Plutarch
Punishment -- Early works to 1800
9. What I have said thus far has been said on the supposition that, as
is generally thought, there is an actual delay in the punishment of
the wicked. But as to what may yet be said on this point, it may be
well for us to listen to Hesiod, who maintains, not, with Plato, that
punishment is a suffering that follows wrong-doing, but that it is a
twin birth with wrong-doing, springing from the same soil and the same
root; for he says,
“Bad counsel does most harm to him who gives it,”
and,
“Who does another wrong himself most wrongs.”
The cantharis,[24:1] by a certain contrast in the elements of its
physical structure, is said to contain within itself the antidote for
the wound which it makes. But—the converse of this—guilt, bringing
with itself into being its own pain and punishment, not subsequently
to, but in the very act of wrong-doing receives its penalty. The
malefactor who is to be crucified carries his cross with his own
body; and in like manner wickedness creates from itself, to be borne
by itself, each several form of chastisement, being, so to speak, an
expert artificer of a wretched life, attended by thronging fears and
distressing emotions, by ceaseless remorse and constant perturbation.
But some persons are like children, who, often seeing in the theatres
malefactors in gold-embroidered tunics and purple mantles, crowned and
dancing, admire and applaud them as happy beings, until they appear on
the stage goaded and scourged, and with fire streaming from their gay
and finely wrought apparel.[25:1] For many of the wicked, surrounded by
large families, and possessed of places of high command and extended
authority, are not visibly punished till they are seen slain or hurled
down a precipice, which ought to be called, not punishment, but the
end or consummation of punishment. As Plato says that Herodicus, the
Selymbrian, being attacked with phthisis, an incurable disease, and
being the first to unite gymnastics with the healing art, made death
long for himself and for those similarly affected; so too such of the
wicked as seem to escape immediate punishment receive, not after a long
time, but during a long time, not a slower, but a longer punishment;
nor are they punished when they grow old, but they grow old in a state
of punishment. Yet it is only to you that I speak of a long time; for
to the gods any period of human life is as nothing, and “now, not
thirty years hence,” is to them as it would be to us for a malefactor
to be put to torture or hanged this evening, and not to-morrow morning.
Besides, one is kept in life as in a prison that has no outlet or mode
of escape; yet he may enjoy frequent feasts, may transact business, may
receive presents and kindnesses, like the men who play with dice or at
draughts in prison, with the rope hanging over their heads.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account