Reformed Logic: A System Based on Berkeley's Philosophy with an Entirely New Method of DialecticMcLachlan, D. B.
Philosophy
Reformed Logic: A System Based on Berkeley's Philosophy with an Entirely New Method of Dialectic
McLachlan, D. B.
Logic
Abstract ideas do not form a fourth class of ideas but are fractions
of particular, general, or imaginary ideas, and may (as Berkeley,
reporting the metaphysical doctrine, says) be single or partial
properties mentally detached from the collective properties forming an
object. In this case they are abstracted properties, not ideas. Since
general ideas are less complete than the particular ideas from which
they were drawn, they are abstract ideas in so far as they are partial
ideas; but all abstract ideas are not general ideas. Berkeley's
nominalism is based on the supposed impossibility of forming any sort
of partial idea, and he now proceeds to reproduce the metaphysical
account of the general abstract idea.
'And as the mind frames to itself abstract ideas of qualities
or modes, so does it, by the same precision or mental
separation, attain abstract ideas [general ideas] of the more
compounded beings which include several co-existent qualities.
For example, the mind having observed that Peter, James, and
John resemble each other in certain common agreements of shape
and other qualities, leaves out of the complex or compounded
idea it has of Peter, James, and any other particular man,
that which is peculiar to each, retaining only what is common
to all, and so makes an abstract [general] idea wherein all
the particulars equally partake--abstracting entirely from and
cutting off those circumstances and differences which might
determine it to any particular existence. And after this
manner it is said we come by the abstract [general] idea of
man, or, if you please, humanity or human nature; wherein it
is true there is included colour, because there is no man but
has some colour, but then it can be neither white, nor black,
nor any particular colour, because there is no one particular
colour wherein all men partake. So likewise there is included
stature, but then it is neither tall stature, nor low stature,
nor yet middle stature, but something abstracted from all
these. And so of the rest. Moreover, there being a great
variety of other creatures that partake of some parts, but not
all, of the complex idea of man, the mind, leaving out those
parts which are peculiar to men, and retaining those only
which are common to all the living creatures, frames the idea
of _animal_, which abstracts not only from all particular
men, but also all birds, beasts, fishes and insects. The
constituent parts of the abstract idea of animal are body,
life, sense, and spontaneous motion. By _body_ is meant body
without any particular shape or figure, there being no one
shape or figure common to all animals, without covering either
of hair, or feathers, or scales, &c., nor yet naked: hair,
feathers, scales, and nakedness being the distinguishing
properties of particular animals, and for that reason left out
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account