Ritual and belief : $b Studies in the history of religion — John Shaqi
Ritual and belief : $b Studies in the history of religionHartland, Edwin Sidney
Religion
Ritual and belief : $b Studies in the history of religion
Hartland, Edwin Sidney
Ethnopsychology; Magic; Religion; Rites and ceremonies
The opportunity of blundering in the endeavour to understand and
report the beliefs and usages of the lower races is obviously as great
as could be desired. When to the various causes enumerated above is
added not merely the conscious want of sympathy on the part of the
observer, but his unconscious prejudice in favour of {19} certain
interpretations derived from the civilized and the specifically
Christian notions in which he has been brought up from his youth, the
wonder is not that so many mistakes have been made, but that we have
on the whole succeeded in obtaining so large a mass of fairly
trustworthy information. Even that of which we are the best assured,
however, must be used with caution. It must be criticized, checked
with other accounts of the same or neighbouring tribes; and allowance
must be made for the personal equation of the observer. The use of a
word like _worship_, _spirit_, or _God_, which connotes to us very
different ideas from those connoted to the native mind by the native
word thus translated, must put us at once on our guard. Fancied
resemblances between the myths, heard perhaps at second-hand and only
half-understood, and some story, Biblical or other, known to the
reporter, and the expectation of finding in savage tradition some
fragment of divine revelation have proved real Will-o’-the-wisps to
the unwary. Nor must we forget that things actually seen are also
liable to be misinterpreted. Captain John Smith, in writing of
Virginia, describes as a human sacrifice--a sacrifice of
children--what seems to have been no more than the ceremony of
initiation into manhood.[19.1] It is true that his account was
written three hundred years ago, and that he was not allowed to
witness the whole performance. But after all our subsequent experience
and accumulation of records, nothing is harder even yet than to
determine the meaning of ceremonies and institutions, often carefully
examined and minutely described by skilled eyewitnesses and scientific
explorers.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account