Sir Thomas Browne, writing in 1681-2 to his son Edward who was by way of
translating the _Lives_ of Plutarch, and in fact accomplished two of
them, assumes that he will in the main follow Amyot’s version, which
North had followed absolutely, and suggests that, with some corrections
and the removal of obsolete words, North’s work might still serve
‘especially with gentlemen, who if the expression bee playne looke not
into criticisme’. ‘If you have the Greek Plutarke,’ he writes, ‘have
also the Latin adjoyned unto it, so you may consult either upon
occasion, though you apply yourself to translate out of French, and the
English translation may be sometimes helpful.’ Very likely an acceptable
version of the _Moralia_ might now be produced out of Amyot and Philemon
Holland, a racy and scholarly translator from the Greek, with the
original and the old Latin at hand for reference. But Dr. Edward Browne
was a physician, of little leisure and of delicate health, and it might
hardly be respectful to Plutarch to adopt this procedure now; indeed it
seems to recall that of ‘the dog’ in the proverb, who ‘drinks from the
Nile’, running as he drinks, always with an eye on the crocodiles.
However this may be, some indulgence may fairly be claimed by a
translator of an author, who, however straight-forward himself, abounds
in allusion and latent quotation, and also in difficulties of text not
of his own making, and upon whom no commentary exists. I will mention,
for the sake of clearness, two instances as to which I have troubled
myself and, I fear, others a good deal:
In the dialogue _On the Genius of Socrates_, chap. iii, end (577 A), the
speaker says that his brother Epaminondas is keeping out of the
patriotic enterprise in hand, on the ground that the more hot-headed
members of the party will not stop short of a general massacre and the
murder of many of the leading citizens.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account