The books of Chronicles : $b With maps, notes and introductionElmslie, W. A. L. (William Alexander Leslie)
History
The books of Chronicles : $b With maps, notes and introduction
Elmslie, W. A. L. (William Alexander Leslie)
Bible. Chronicles -- Commentaries
¹ Such omissions are very skilfully managed by the Chronicler.
Even so, they generally entail some abrupt transition or
obscurity, as in the present instance for which see the
note on 1 Chronicles xi. 1. Here the cause of the obscurity
can be shown by direct comparison of the earlier history
in Samuel. Mark how usefully Chronicles thus demonstrates
the _legitimacy_ of the argument that similar difficulties
elsewhere in the Old Testament are perhaps due to a similar
cause, although the earlier source may not be extant to
prove that the conjecture is correct.
The conclusions to be drawn from the above are clear. First, in
passages of the type instanced in (ii) above, where the differences
between Kings and Chronicles are considerable and not confined to
changes made on transparently religious grounds, the possibility that
we have to do with a variant form of the tradition in Kings should be
carefully considered. If there be any such distinct traditions, even
though they are few or in a late stage of development, they are of
high value, for they _may_ be as worthy of consideration as the form
in Kings. Moreover a slight variation in a tradition may occasionally
suffice to indicate the existence of a different standpoint towards an
important topic or period in the history. But in the majority of _all_
cases included under this heading (I) it appears that the changes in
the narratives were arbitrarily made in consequence of the standpoint,
beliefs, and purpose (§§ 1 and 6) of the Chronicler, and they can make
no claim to rest on historical facts. For the detailed arguments upon
which this general conclusion is based, the reader is referred to the
notes on the text.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account