The Evolution of StatesRobertson, J. M. (John Mackinnon)
History
The Evolution of States
Robertson, J. M. (John Mackinnon)
Europe -- Politics and government; Great Britain -- Politics and government; Political science -- History
Since the first edition of the present work there has appeared, in
Dr. G.B. Grundy's _Thucydides and the History of his Age_ (1911) a
new recognition of the fundamental character of economic conditions
in Greek as in other history. Dr. Grundy, finding no academic
precedent for his sociological method, has urged as new truths
propositions which for economic historians are or should have been
axioms. The result, however, is a really stimulating and valuable
presentment of Greek history in terms of causal forces.
The chapters on Greece in Dr. Cunningham's _Western Civilisation_
(1898), though they contain not a few explanations of Greek
culture-phenomena on the old lines, in terms of themselves, are
helpful for the purposes of the present inquiry, since they really
study causation, as do Meyer's _Wirthschaftliche Entwickelung des
Alterthums_ and some other recent German treatises, of which Dr.
Cunningham makes use.
Much use, however, remains to be made of these and previous expert
studies. Boeckh's great work on the _Public Economy of the
Athenians_, which, though containing economic absurdities, hardly
deserves even in that regard the strictures passed on it by the
first English translator (Sir G.C. Lewis, 1828; 2nd ed. 1842;
superior American ed. tr. from 2nd German ed. by A. Lamb, 1857),
has not very fruitfully affected the later historians proper. The
third German edition by Fränkel, 1886, typifies the course of
scholarship. It corrects details and adds a mass of _apparatus
criticus_ equal in bulk to the whole original work, but supplies no
new ideas. Heeren's section on Greece in his _Ideen_, etc.,
translated as a _Sketch of the Political History of Ancient Greece_
(1829), and also as part of Heeren's _Thoughts on the Politics_,
etc., of _the Ancient World_, is too full of early misconceptions
to be well worth returning to, save for its general view. On the
other hand, Grote's great _History of Greece_, though unmatched in
its own species, and though a far more philosophical performance
than that of Mitford (which Professor Mahaffy and the King of
Greece agree in preferring for its doctrine), is substantially a
narrative and critical history on the established lines, and does
not aim at being more than incidentally sociological; and that of
Bishop Thirlwall, though in parts superior in this regard, is
substantially in similar case. At several points, indeed, Grote
truly illuminates the sociological problem--notably in his view of
the reactions between the Greek drama and the Greek life. Of the
German general histories, that of Holm (Eng. tr. 4 vols. 1894-98)
is a trustworthy and judicious embodiment of the latest research,
but has no special intellectual weight, and is somewhat needlessly
prolix. The history of Dr.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account