The great betrayal (La trahison des clercs)Benda, Julien
Philosophy
The great betrayal (La trahison des clercs)
Benda, Julien
Intellectuals; Nationalism; Philosophy, Modern
Some ‘clerks’ do better, and assert that by extolling national
particularisms they are in complete harmony with the fundamental spirit
of the Church, especially with the teaching of the great Doctors of
the Middle Ages. (This is the thesis which opposes Catholicism to
Christianity.) Need I recall the fact that the most national of these
Doctors limited themselves to considering national particularisms as an
inevitable condition of an earthly and inferior world, which must be
respected like everything else which is the will of God? Or that they
never exhorted men to intensify this feeling in their hearts, still
less did they ever think of putting this intensification before them as
an exercise in moral self-perfection?
When the Church in past times did approve of something in patriotism,
it was fraternity among fellow-citizens, like love of man for other
men, but not his opposition to other men. She approved of patriotism as
an extension of human love, and not as a limitation of it.[66]
But the most remarkable thing in all this is that recently--precisely
since the time when Benedict XV was reproached during the last war for
not having denounced the arrogance of German nationalism--there has
arisen a school in the bosom of the Church which tries to prove that
by acting in this way the Holy Father had simply obeyed the teaching
of his Divine Master, who is supposed to have preached explicitly the
love of a man for his own nation. Could anything better symbolize the
determination of the modern ‘clerks’ to place their credit and their
activities at the service of lay passions than these Churchmen making
Jesus an apostle of nationalism?
These strange Christians express themselves thus:
‘Jesus does not look beyond the frontiers of his own country with the
idea of bestowing his benefactions upon other nations. He declares to
the Canaanitish woman, whose daughter he heals against his own wish,
that “his mission is only to the lost sheep of the house of Israel”
(Matt. xv, 24). He sent his first disciples among the Israelites. And
notice how he insists that they shall not go elsewhere. “Go not on the
paths of the Gentiles, and enter not the cities of the Samaritans, but
go first to the lost sheep of the house of Israel.” (Matt. x, 6.) Later
on, it will be time enough to announce the good news to foreigners,
but first of all we must bring it to our own people. This is what he
means by the words, so full of patriotic meaning and love: “the house
of Israel.” A group of human beings possessing the same blood, the same
language, the same religion, the same tradition, form “a house”. These
particularities are so many dividing walls.’[67]
They also say:
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account