The historical novel : $b An essayButterfield, Herbert
History
The historical novel : $b An essay
Butterfield, Herbert
Historical fiction -- History and criticism
This is a description of a mere relationship between classes of a
society. Scott sees in it a story. He divines in it just the situations
and issues out of which a story can be made. He sees its implications
in individual lives. Instead of contemplating its effects on future
generations he lays bare its workings in the scheme of life of people
who lived under it. Just as a prism catches the light and turns it into
colours he stands between the historical generalisation and his readers
and he breaks up the general into the particular and projects it as a
picture. The result is like the condensing of a cloud into raindrops.
Fiction is like the dust which creates a sunbeam and helps the sunlight
to show that it is there. And in this way Scott does something for
history that the historian by himself cannot do, or can seldom do; he
recaptures the life of an age, and resurrects a picture of the past.
The historical novelist receives his hint from history, but such
examples as these from _Ivanhoe_ are enough to make it apparent that
this hint need not necessarily be a story ready-made, a sequence of
events to be followed. Many historical novels are stories straight
from a history-book--the adventures of Guy Fawkes, the sorrows of Mary
Queen of Scots--amplified and rounded off by fiction perhaps, and
re-told with some variations. History may provide plot and adventure,
and fiction may just fill in the lines where history is inadequate
or idealise incidents and careers where history is incomplete or
disappointing. It is claimed of some of Jokai’s novels that, staged
as they are in lands where passion and action are intense and full
of colour, and drawn as they are from a history that is crowded with
romantic and thrilling episodes, they do not need an invention of
incident or a perversion of history to make them complete, but are just
a vivid re-telling of things that actually happened. The books of Dumas
are filled with incidents and situations that are picked straight from
history and are marvellously connected into an organised story. And
many writers have assimilated into the body of their novels incidents
that are true to fact or anecdotes from legend, and so have made
history and fiction fit into each other in dovetail fashion. All this
represents one way in which history can be incorporated into a novel,
but it is not the only way; and the particular fact that is brought to
light by the Introduction to _Ivanhoe_, as well as by other things,
is the fact that history does not merely inspire fiction by providing
a tale, a thread of incident, a network of action, to be re-told in
story-book fashion; it may only provoke a tale, it may just provide
situations and relationships and problems which give the right kind
of issue that is needed in story-making. Scott saw implicit in the
conditions of the age of Richard I a set of human relationships which
were materials for a novel. He had the power of divining the implied
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account