The Idiot: His Place in Creation, and His Claims on SocietyBateman, Frederick, Sir
Science
The Idiot: His Place in Creation, and His Claims on Society
Bateman, Frederick, Sir
Mental retardation; Stupidity
Although the physiological effects of thyroid feeding may not be
definitely recognised and understood, there is overwhelming evidence
to show that it produces marked psychical results, that it acts as a
direct cerebral stimulant, and we have every reason to rely upon it as
a valuable adjuvant to our treatment of idiocy; and it is not too much
to say that the treatment of this infirmity, as well as of other
mental defects, by thyroid extract or some other preparation of the
thyroid gland, is one of the greatest triumphs of modern medicine; but
much still remains to be learnt, as Professor Victor Horsley remarks,
"So definite and pronounced is the cachexia thyroidectomica, that few
subjects in the range of pathology offer a more fruitful and inviting
field of research."[48]
_Craniectomy._--The operation of Craniectomy (that is the cutting of
strips of bone from the cranium) has been recommended and practised in
cases of microcephalic idiocy, an operation suggested upon the theory
of premature synostosis, or closure of the cranial sutures, thus
causing an arrest in the development of the subjacent cerebral tissue.
Although I could not omit a reference to this operation, it has not
met with general acceptance, and one of the most recent writers on
this subject, M. Bourneville, physician at Bicêtre, discourages it
altogether; and from his examination of the skulls of a number of
idiots, he affirms that "in the immense majority of cases, there was
no premature synostosis, and that neither normal anatomy,
pathological anatomy, or physiology, justified the operation of
Craniectomy."[49] The late Sir George Humphry was of the same opinion,
as, after an examination of 19 microcephalic skulls, he said, "There
is nothing to suggest that the deficiency in the development of the
skull was the leading feature in the deformity, or anything to give
encouragement to the practice lately adopted in some instances of a
removal of a part of the bony case, with the idea of affording more
space and freedom for the growth of the brain."[50]
At a recent meeting of the New York State Medical Society, Professor
Dana read a paper on Craniectomy for Idiocy and Imbecility, and he
gave the following result of 81 cases:--In 35, there was improvement;
in 22, no improvement; and death ensued in 24 cases. The conclusion at
which Professor Dana arrives is that "it is largely through its
pedagogic influence that an improvement takes place, and that the
operation is allied in its effect to a severe piece of castigation!"
Dr. Dana freely admits that this view of craniectomy for idiocy and
imbecility lends itself readily to humour, and it would seem that he
intended to kill the operation by ridicule.[51]
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account