The Irish Ecclesiastical Record, Volume 1, March 1865 — John Shaqi
The Irish Ecclesiastical Record, Volume 1, March 1865
History
The Irish Ecclesiastical Record, Volume 1, March 1865
Catholic Church -- Ireland -- Periodicals; Catholic Church -- Periodicals
But perhaps Dr Colenso would prefer to be judged by the authority
of the Hebrew text. Those who were numbered are described by the
words כָּל־ יֹצֵ֥א צָבָ֖א (kol yotze tzaba)--_every one going forth to the
host_. In the opinion of Dr. Colenso this must mean every one belonging
to the army--every _armed warrior_. Let us see if this interpretation is
borne out by the use of the same phrase in other passages. We find it
prescribed (_Numbers_, viii. 25) that at the age of fifty the Levites
shall return from the _host_ (צָבָ֖א--tzaba) of the service". Now, it is
well known that the Levites were not permitted to serve in the army.
Therefore, the word _host_ (צָבָ֖א) does not here mean the _army_, but, as
all commentators explain it, the body of Levites engaged in the active
service of the Tabernacle. Again, we read (_Gen._ ii. 1). "The heavens
and the earth were finished, and all the _host_ (צָבָ֖א) of them". In this
passage the word manifestly refers to the works of the creation which
had just been completed. It is also frequently applied by the prophets
to the heavenly bodies,[12] and to the choirs of angels.[13] This word,
therefore, in its primary sense, would seem to represent a collection
of men or things _marshalled in order_. Frequently, indeed, and most
fitly, it was used to designate an army; but we deny that it was employed
exclusively in that signification.
If, then, we seek to ascertain its exact meaning in the first chapter
of _Numbers_, we must examine the context in which it is found, and the
circumstances to which it refers. Moses is commanded by God to number
the people, and the way in which he executed that command is accurately
described. There is not a word, in this, or the following chapters,
about soldiers, or arms, or warfare. The object of the census was simply
to distribute the people of Israel, according to their tribes and
families, around the Tabernacle which stood in the midst of the camp.
The position of each tribe was clearly defined, with a view to the
preservation of strict order and regularity. May we not, then, fairly
infer that by the _host_ is here meant the whole people of Israel
_marshalled_, as they were, _in order_ around the Tabernacle? It is
probable that those only were numbered who were responsible members of
the community, that is to say, all the fathers of families.
We conclude that the argument of Dr. Colenso fails to establish any
inconsistency in the sacred narrative: first, because it is quite
uncertain that the Israelites are said to have been _armed_; secondly,
because it is simply false that they are represented to have had 600,000
_armed warriors_.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account