The logic of modern physicsBridgman, P. W. (Percy Williams)
Philosophy
The logic of modern physics
Bridgman, P. W. (Percy Williams)
Physics -- Philosophy
The first step in resuming our explanatory progress, after we have been
confronted with such a crisis, is to seek for various sorts of
correlation between the elements of our new experience, in the confident
expectation that these elements will eventually become so familiar to us
that they may be used as the ultimates of a new explanation. This is
exactly what is now happening in quantum theory.
Diametrically opposed to the views above, there is another ideal of the
explanatory process which is held by many physicists, and which has been
mentioned above as the third possible way in which the explanatory
sequence may be terminated, namely, the endeavor to devise beyond the
limit of present experiment a structure built of elements like some of
those of our present experience, in the action of which we endeavor to
find the explanation of phenomena in the present range. Now a program
such as this, as a serious program for the final correlation of nature,
is entirely opposed to the spirit of the considerations expounded here.
There is no warrant whatever in experience for the conviction that as we
penetrate deeper and deeper we shall find the elements of previous
experience repeated, although sometimes we do find such repetitions, as
in the behavior of gases. Yet this has been the attitude of many eminent
physicists, for example, Faraday and Maxwell, in seeking to explain
distant electrical action by the propagation through a medium of a
mechanical push or pull, or by Hertz, who sought in all phenomena the
effect of concealed masses with ordinary mechanical inertia. Although as
a general principle this program seems to be absolutely without
justification, nevertheless it may be justified if the specific
character of the physical facts seems to indicate a repetition at lower
levels of elements familiar higher up. Hertz undoubtedly had this
justification, as did also Maxwell to a certain extent, in the discovery
that the general equations of electrodynamics are of the same form as
the generalized Lagrangean equations of mechanics. For Faraday, however,
there seems no such justification; the urge to this sort of thing in
Faraday came from an uncritical acceptance of his own temperamental
reactions.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account