The Place of Science in Modern Civilisation, and Other EssaysVeblen, Thorstein
Philosophy
The Place of Science in Modern Civilisation, and Other Essays
Veblen, Thorstein
Economics; Science
The case is illustrated by the latter-day history of theoretical
physics. Of the sciences which affect a non-committal attitude in
respect of the concept of efficiency and which claim to get along with
the notion of mathematical function alone, physics is the most outspoken
and the one in which the claim has the best _prima facie_ validity. At
the same time, latter-day physicists, for a hundred years or more, have
been much occupied with explaining how phenomena which to all appearance
involve action at a distance do not involve action at a distance at all.
The greater theoretical achievements of physics during the past century
lie within the sweep of this (metaphysical) principle that action at a
distance does not take place, that apparent action at a distance must be
explained by effective contact, through a continuum, or by a material
transference. But this principle is nothing better than an unreasoning
repugnance on the part of the physicists to admitting action at a
distance. The requirement of a continuum involves a gross form of the
concept of efficient causation. The "functional" concept, concomitant
variation, requires no contact and no continuum. Concomitance at a
distance is quite as simple and convincing a notion as concomitance
within contact or by the intervention of a continuum, if not more so.
What stands in the way of its acceptance is the irrepressible
anthropomorphism of the physicists. And yet the great achievements of
physics are due to the initiative of men animated with this
anthropomorphic repugnance to the notion of concomitant variation at a
distance. All the generalisations on undulatory motion and translation
belong here. The latter-day researches in light, electrical
transmission, the theory of ions, together with what is known of the
obscure and late-found radiations and emanations, are to be credited to
the same metaphysical preconception, which is never absent in any
"scientific" inquiry in the field of physical science. It is only the
"occult" and "Christian" "Sciences" that can dispense with this
metaphysical postulate and take recourse to "absent treatment."
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account