The Problem of 'Edwin Drood': A Study in the Methods of DickensNicoll, W. Robertson (William Robertson), Sir
General
The Problem of 'Edwin Drood': A Study in the Methods of Dickens
Nicoll, W. Robertson (William Robertson), Sir
Cathedrals in literature; Dickens, Charles, 1812-1870. Mystery of Edwin Drood; Murder in literature
Madame Perugini’s article appeared in the _Pall Mall Magazine_ for June
1906. The title is ‘Edwin Drood and the Last Days of Charles Dickens, by
his younger daughter Kate Perugini.’ Madame Perugini begins by
summarising the evidence of Forster as already given. She proceeds to
make the following instructive comments. It will be observed also that
she makes no additions to the external evidence, particularly on the
vexed question of the wrapper:
_The Mystery of Edwin Drood_ is a story, or, to speak more correctly,
the half of a story, that has excited so much general interest and so
many speculations as to its ultimate disclosures, that it has given
rise to various imaginary theories on the part of several clever
writers; and to much discussion among those who are not writers, but
merely fervent admirers and thoughtful readers of my father’s
writings. All these attach different meanings to the extraordinary
number of clues my father has offered them to follow, and they are
even more keen at the present day than they were when the book made
its first appearance to find their way through the tangled maze and
arrive at the very heart of the mystery. Among the numerous books,
pamphlets, and articles that have been written upon _Edwin Drood_,
there are some that are extremely interesting and well worth
attention, for they contain many clever and possible suggestions, and
although they do not entirely convince us, yet they add still more to
the almost painful anxiety we all feel in wandering through the
lonely precincts of Cloisterham Cathedral, or along the banks of the
river that runs through Cloisterham town and leads to the Weir of
which we are told in the story.
In following these writers to the end of their subtle imaginings as
to how the mystery might be solved, we may sometimes be inclined to
pause for an instant and ask ourselves whether my father did not
perhaps intend his story to have an ending less complicated, although
quite as interesting, as any that are suggested. We find ourselves
turning to John Forster’s _Life of Charles Dickens_ to help us in our
perplexity, and this is what we read in his chapter headed ‘Last
Book.’ Mr. Forster begins by telling us that _Edwin Drood_ was to be
published in twelve illustrated monthly parts, and that it closed
prematurely with the sixth number, which was itself underwritten by
two pages; therefore my father had exactly six numbers and two pages
to write when he left his little châlet in the shrubbery of Gad’s
Hill Place on 8th June 1870, to which he never returned. Mr. Forster
goes on to say: ‘His first fancy for the tale was expressed in July
(meaning the July of 1869), in a letter which runs thus:
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account